16 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful
Dama reviewed Birdsong: A Novel of Love and War on
Helpful Score: 4
I found this novel to be dissapointing. The relationship between Stephen and Isabelle was more about lust, curiosity, and escape. It was finished before it even began. Most of the story is about the details of WWI, which was fine, but the exaggeration of details made this book drag. Too many characters and not enough character build-up. The ending seemed rushed, therefore, fell flat. The story could have gone along without the character of Elizabeth. Not an impressive novel in my opinion.
This book has been on my TBR shelf for almost 4 years. I finally decided to read it when I heard that a BBC adaptation of the novel is scheduled to be aired on PBS' Masterpiece. The first part of this was shown last weekend and the conclusion this coming Sunday (I have my DVR set to record). Anyway, I thought the novel was wonderful telling the story of a young British man, Wraysford, who finds love in France prior to WWI. He falls for the wife of a man who he is staying with in France to learn about the fabric trade. Then the novel throws the reader into the midst of the horrors of the Great War. Faulks is very graphic in his descriptions of both love and war. The novel then shifts between the horrors of the trenches to the 1970s and Wraysford's granddaughter who is trying to find out more about her grandfather and what it was like during WWI. Overall, I would highly recommend this novel, especially to anyone interested in learning more about WWI, and I'm looking forward to watching the BBC adaptation.
I just couldn't get into this book. The author writes in such a style that you aren't able to get to know the characters on a personal level (if that makes any sense). I felt like I was reading about people just going through the motions.
I had heard how raw and honest this book was. I resisted reading it because of the Incomprehensible horrors of war with nothing-held-back descriptions of the trenches. Faulks had me so mesmerized with Charlotte Gray (set in WWII) that I decided to read this WWI novel.
The contrived nature of the romance (clearly sexual) between Stephen and Isabelle Azaire (nine years his senior) didnt hold up to the vivid war story.
There are two narratives: first by Stephen Wraysford, who failed to gain my sympathy, but kept my attention. The second is by Stephens daughter Elizabeth, which didnt make sense until I reached the end of the book. Both the sex and battle scenes are graphic and unsettling, but the book is a wonderful account of what sacrifices were made by those who fought in WWI. Especially interesting are the digging of fighting tunnels and the brave men who dug them. The book will both tear your out heart and grip your soul. It helped me understand why my father told us nothing about his experiences in the artillery of WWII.
"It was not his death that mattered; it was the way the world had been dislocated. It was not all the tens of thousands of deaths that mattered; it was the way they had proved that you could be human yet act in a way that was beyond nature." (p. 225)
No child or future generation will ever know what this was likeWhen it is over we will go quietly among the living and we will not tell themWe will seal what we have seen in the silence of our hearts and no words will reach us. (p. 403) And yet, Sebastian Faulks attempts to tell us.
Very descriptive of WW1 life in the trenches and love story all in one. Was a little hard to get into at first. I couldn't put it down wanting to figure out the connection to the main characters. Very worthwhile read.
I just couldn't get started on this book. I tried several times to begin reading it, but found it's only attribute to be the ability to lull me to sleep immediately. Sorry, I'm sure it is probably a sleeper, but I just didn't have the patience.
Very powerful, poignant novel set mostly in France just in theÂ years before and during WWI. Evokes memories of All Quiet on the Western Front and For Whom the Bell Tolls. Wonderfully-drawn characters of men and women. A memorable book well worth the read.
I have to agree with reviewers who struggled with this book or found it disappointing. I too, thought the romance between Stephen & Isabelle was not too believable. I liked that Stephen's granddaughter was searching to know more about him, and the scene with Stephen's former comrade from the trenches, the old man in the rest home, is very moving. The WWI scenes are excellent and the soldiers and the situation that Faulks creates are very "real". Therefore, I found the novel somewhat uneven - half great; half not very good. Maybe if he'd jettisoned the romantic affair, it would actually have been a better novel (for me).
Not knowing much of the History of WWI, I found this book to be so full of new information that I have gone on to read more about WWI. The story was interesting, especially about the miners from Wales.
Intensely romantic and stunningly realistic novel and international bestseller. Spans 3 generations, spanning WWI to present. As young Englishman Stephen Wraysford passes through a tempestuous love affair with Isabelle Azaire in France and enters the dark, surreal world in the trenches. This book is about the ruins of war and the indestructibility of love. As tragic as A Farewell to Arms, as sensual as The English Patient.
A romantic novel that spans three generations and the unimaginable gulf between the first World War and the present. As the young Englishman Stephan Wraysford passes through a tempestuous love affair with Isabelle Azaire in France and enters the dark, surreal world beneath the trenches of No Man's Land.