Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Search - Hollywood's Silent Closet

Hollywood's Silent Closet
Hollywood's Silent Closet
Author: Darwin Porter
Compiled from hundreds of interviews with survivors of the Silent Screen era, this is the most intimate and most realistic novel ever written about sex, murder, blackmail, and degradation in early Hollywood. It's based on the loose-lipped gossip that was articulated within the drunken dinner parties of 1920s-era Hollywood. Many of the stories ...  more »
ISBN-13: 9780966803020
ISBN-10: 0966803027
Publication Date: 4/2001
Pages: 750
Edition: 1
Rating:
  • Currently 1.7/5 Stars.
 3

1.7 stars, based on 3 ratings
Publisher: Georgia Literary Association
Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
Members Wishing: 3
Reviews: Member | Amazon | Write a Review
Read All 3 Book Reviews of "Hollywoods Silent Closet"

Please Log in to Rate these Book Reviews

kww avatar reviewed Hollywood's Silent Closet on + 18 more book reviews
A complete and utter joke and poorly written at that. Had I known this was fanfic, I would never have wasted a credit on it. I'm sure there's better gay erotica out there. This is just sludge.
palmerfan avatar reviewed Hollywood's Silent Closet on + 8 more book reviews
Totaly unbeliveable. According to him, he's had sex with every male movie star he met. Every situation. He could not leave the house without coming into contact with a movie star(sometimes 2 or 3) and having sex with them.
gaslight avatar reviewed Hollywood's Silent Closet on + 145 more book reviews
If anyone is familiar with the fanfiction genre, RPS is "Real Person Slash" - a story written by someone who wants to have famous guys (or gals) getting it on with each other. Sometimes the author wishes to become part of the story (called "self-insert") and so an original character has sex with famous people. There are fics aplenty out there about some dazzled fangirl making it with Orlando Bloom or Johnny Depp or the entire cast of Lord of the Rings. There's also fics about Eric Bana and Brad Pitt finding true love on the set of "Troy" or Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert being more than just reporting buddies. This is what Darwin Porter's written, only it's about the stud stable of Silent Hollywood.

Now I'm not blaming Porter for wanting to scribble out his little fantasies or the fantasies of this Stanley Mills Haggart who he says served as his muse. Crikey, I did the same thing when I was 16 and hormonal. My character romped through the beds of Hollywood and German WWI aces with as much aplomb and shamlessness as Porter's Durango Jones. Alas, she was a girl and therefore my little effort apparently has no chance of getting published. Is the title pool of gay lit really so small that this doorstopper is a welcome addition to the genre?

Yet this was a hilarious read simply because the book was full of crap. Aimee Semple McPherson's Angelus Temple wasn't dedicated until 1923. It was not a beacon of Pentecostal excess in late 1918 the way Porter has written it. Still, I overlooked egregious historical errors like that just because it was so hilariously awful.

If you're an MST3K fan and don't mind reading badly-written gay porn, this book isn't a total waste of time. I recommend reading it in doses because the unimaginative prose becomes extremely tedious after a dozen pages. And the "voices" of all the characters are pretty much the same. The men have one personality and voice, and ditto for the women.

And it's inspired me! I'm off to write a story about Lon Chaney and Erich von Stroheim doing it in the backseat of a Stutz Bearcat while Wallace Beery and Ronald Colman 69 it on the roof. It can't lose! It's Literary Gold!

I've discovered that Blood Moon Productions/Georgia Literary Assc. is basically a vanity press for Porter and Danforth Prince. Now it makes sense why this book saw the light of day. I believe it's possible to write good erotic fiction using real-life people, however this isn't anywhere close to it.

Give all my gripes, it was very amusing in its own way. It's just not good, or even mediocre, literature. 3 out of 5.


Genres: