I choose to read this book because it has a story written by Connie Shelton, & i just love her stories, (if you remember she has some cozies that are so fun.) So needless to say her story was my favorite, it was really fun. She also shares her recipe for Mexican Biscochitos, a cookie she makes at x-mas. I was also nicely surprised that i liked the other 3 stories . This is rare for me, usually there is one i don't care for. All four x-mas stories are wonderful and of course by the name of the book you can tell they were all murder "who dun it's". Four good mystery murders ready for x-mas reading.