its a contempary and the hero was brought up amish. sorry i cant remember more, thanks for looking.

Was it a category romance?  Longer book?

Umm, the more I think about it I'm sure it was a category and printed in the 80s. hope this helps.

One of Sandra Hill's "jinx" books has a hero who was raised Amish.

Maple Creek Amish Trilogy by Karen Harper?  There are 3 books in this series

sorry to say that neither of those books are the one i'm looking for. Thanks for the help though. A few more details I've remembered are that it had a predomantly red/orange cover and that it was either a harliquin or shillouette. Thanks for all your help! : )

The Silhouette Desire series has a mostly red cover with a picture in the middle.

I found this list when I googled it. Let us know if any of these were it.

http://www.amazon.com/My-Favorite-Amish-Romance-Novels/lm/3DN4MR1HWN9N2

Cassie you rock!!! It was on that list thank you so much.  This is the book I have been looking for>>>>>

http://www.amazon.com/Crime-Heart-Silhouette-Special-487/dp/0373094876/ref=cm_lmf_tit_9

Thank you to everyone who helped me!!

Always glad to help :)