Unlock Forum posting with Annual Membership. |
|
|||
Do you consider James A. Michener's Chesapeake to be a classic? Why or why not? Have you read any of his other novels? How do they compare? Which is your favorite? I just started reading this last week and am currently 1/3 of the way through. I can't believe I've never read it. I may be biased because I now live in the region, but I'm so intrigued, this is an excellent novel. I love all the intertwined relationships and the scholarship is top notch. My favorite line so far, "...those Americans who lived within the benediction of the Chesapeake ..." (p381). I am reading a library copy, but this is a book I must own. As soon as I get a credit for a book I've mailed, then I'm ordering it.
|
|||
|
|||
I don't know if I consider it a classic (since folks have different definitions of what that should include), but I loved that book. I read it way back in high school, and have recently collected a copy for myself to reread. (Of course, thanks to this site, I have a rather large TBR pile.) I grew up near enough to the region to identify with the terrain and the history in the book, so that may have been part of the appeal for me. I am always impressed with Michener's research, too. After enjoying Chesapeake so much, I tried some of Michener's other books and was never able to get hooked the way I was for Chesapeake. I'm not sure if I just needed to get older to enjoy them, or if I needed the regional connection. (When my TBR pile shrinks, maybe I should try again.)
|
|||
|
|||
There's a kind of a joke about how one gets ready to spend the winter up in "Lake Wobegon" country in Minnesota. Preparations include stocking two or three James Michener books . . . . Personally, the Michener tome that impressed me was Hawaii. I found the interactions between all the different racial and ethnic groups fascinating. The writer does "flesh out" his characters pretty well, doesn't he? |
|||
|
|||
I'm not sure what genre Michener's books would fall into. Not classics. Looking at the forums, I wonder about putting them under historical fiction, but that doesn't seem right either, because the books are so all-emcompassing as far as timeframes for a region. Anyway, yes, I've read and enjoyed Chesapeake. I'd also recommend Centennial and Texas. On the other hand, one I could not get interested in was Space. I have a copy of Tales of the South Pacific (which is not nearly as BIG as the others) on my to be read list. |
|||
|
|||
I'm kind of jumping in here and I apologize. I read some of Michener's books a long time ago. Last night I was looking up the meaning of some book-related words - I think it started with "potboiler" - and I ran onto "airplane book." I'd never heard of this (it's on Wikipedia, of course, lol). I was astounded to find Michener mentioned there. Boy, somebody reads faster than I do or else they had long flights! BTW, I was also looking for a definition of "historical fiction" since the line between some of these genres was confusing me. I know there will be a certain amount of overlap but I was having some problems getting any handle on it. BTW, I enjoyed whatever Michener book(s) I read at the time. (Edited because I checked and I'd definitely read Hawaii and not Tales of the South Pacific.) Last Edited on: 10/16/08 8:41 AM ET - Total times edited: 1 |
|||
|
|||
Let me ask in this thread - what's Michener's best book? If somebody had never read any Michener, and thought he should check out at least one book by the guy, what would be the best one to read? |
|||
|
|||
I would suggest that you select one featuring a geographic area that you are familar with or interested in. I hope others who have read more Michener novels, will also respond with specific title recommendations. Once I finish Chesapeake, I plan to read The world is my home, which is not a novel, but autobiography. Please post your thoughts here once you make your selection. |
|||
|
|||
I've only read one Michener---Hawaii. I am thoroughly glad I read it, because it was huge and quite an accomplishment. It was about 800 pages. I felt like I'd finished a long-distance race when I finally finished it. I was exhausted sometimes at the middle. But by the end, well--the scope, spance and sheer grandeur of it all was so interesting. But whew! It was long and sometimes tiresome. But also enthralling and a page-turner. I am very glad I stuck with it and gutted through it. Because now I can say, "I've read a Michener". |
|||
|
|||
I have to agree with Matthew--start with one that features a geographic area that you identify with. I think that's why I enjoyed Chesapeake so much. Because of my interest, Michener's detailed research-based prose wasn't tedious to read. I'll have to look at his titles again. Now that I've moved a couple of times, it occurs to me that I may find some of his other novels more interesting. |
|||
|
|||
Rick, I would definitely read Chesapeake. SOme of his I can read and some not, but I really think that one is the best. It's on my list to re-read. I read it before I lived in Maryland, and don't live there now, but there are images he created in my head that have lasted since 1983, and which frequently surface. For example, every time I hear or read "Quaker" or see of even hear a goose. |
|||
|
|||
Well, given that I grew up in Maryland, and went to school and lived in Virginia, and I trust jk h's recommendations, I better make it Chesapeake. goodreads.com rates The Source a bit higher, but I'll read Chesapeake. If I like it, I'll read another one. |
|||
|
|||
Just remember when the canvas is that large, the paint's a little thin! Like Rutherford's books. |
|||
|
|||
In my "defense," I don't believe Michener had even written Cheseapeake when I was reading him. Now I can't believe I once read such long books. Who stole my attention span? |
|||
|
|||
The first Michener I read was The Drifters. Then Recessional and The Source. I've read half of Poland and the first 50 pages of Hawaii. His books are truely amazing. I consiter failure to finish my issue, not his. I esspecally love The Source. I would love to read it again, but it is very, very long.
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks for the recommendation, Matthew--I've lived in Hampton Roads, VA for almost six years, so I guess Chesapeake would be a good intro to Michener for me, too! |
|||
|
|||
I make a point to read a Michener novel at least once a calender year. I've read Centenial which is the only novel by him to be made into a motion picture. I think it was his most widely sold novel. Earlier this year I read Texas at 1311 pages it is the longest novel I have ever read. There are a couple of fairly short novels by him, 300-400 pages called Legacy and The Journey. They pretty good reads also. Interesting discussion about reading the novel first that closley matches where you live. As I mentioned above Centenial was my first Michener novel. While Centenial takes place in Colorado's high plains it's the closest geographicaly to where I live. Chesapeak hadn't even corssed my mind because it's 'back east' For 2009 I'm leaning toward The Source for my yearly Michener novel. |
|||
|
|||
Heh! I reside in Hawaii, but haven't reread the book since moving here 21 years ago. I read it as a teen, many years back and was enthralled by the "lusty" parts of it (the way only a teen boy can be.) I am really more a fan of non-fiction and science fiction nowadays, but looking back, my favorite of Michener is The Source. Stories within a story makes for suitable intervals of reading without trying to hold onto too many characters at once. Covers a VERY long time period in the Holy Land. I have read Centennial and I think Chesapeake, too. So long ago. I know I read Caravans and Tales of the South Pacific as well. I also attempted The Drifters but found it trite and insipid. I think most reviewers of the time of its release agree. If I were looking for another to read of his, it might be The Covenant, about South Africa... |
|||
|
|||
Michener's Caribbean is an excellent read. Like most of his work it is extraordinarily long but in the end worth it. |
|||
|
|||
I read Chesapeake a long time ago and loved it. I would also recommend The Covenant. My thing with Michener is that he always seems to start at the beginning of time, but once you get into the book--it is fantastic. You definitely learn about a region of the world. The only one that I tried but could not get into was Poland. |
|||
|
|||
I'm glad I came across this thread. I picked up a couple of his books at a library sale but I haven't ventured reading them yet because they are so thick. I am going to try to read them this year. It's hard for me to read as many books right now because I am going to school full time and working full t ime but I will try to read them. |
|||