Unlock Forum posting with Annual Membership. |
|
|||
First, I must say that I did check the help docs in reference to the eligibility of Pamphlets/Booklets. It says:
The "book" in question, "Jiffy Mixes Recipes--Hospitality in a Jiffy" does not have an ISBN, but the member who posted it claims it does, and entered a 6 digit ISBN. I know that this is false, because sitting beside me is the very pamphlet someone might pay a credit for, when they could go directly to Jiffy's website and get the pamphlet sent to them for free. No shipping/no handling/not one cent out of pocket/no obligations, etc, etc. I think I might've broken rules, too, because I tagged it as a free pamphlet from Jiffy's website. What else, if anything, can be done to get this free pamphet removed? I collect cookbooks, and if I hadn't known that this was a free pamphlet, I might have ordered it and I'd be very unhappy when I received it. (It seriously looks like it could've been a newspaper insert/advertisement with Jiffy recipes.) I just want to be proactive and avoid someone else's RWAP situation.
|
|||
|
|||
I can't help you exactly to tell you that from what I'm thinking they entered it as a book without an ISBN and the system generated an unique ISBN for it--that's what the 5 or 6 digit ISBN is.
I also think that at this point until you get further help, tagging it the way you did is perfectly fine. |
|||
|
|||
In the Questions about PBS forum, there's a sticky at the top called "Report Suspicious Items." That's exactly what it's for--to report items that have been posted that are outside the guidelines. If you copy your description and give the ISBN, it looks like TPTB will look into it. |
|||
|
|||
oops--duplicate post Last Edited on: 2/17/09 8:53 AM ET - Total times edited: 1 |
|||
|
|||
Yeah this sounds like somethign that shouldn't be posted. I would do what Victoria said and report it to the suspicious items thread. |
|||
|
|||
I agree with Mary. I have the exact same pamphlet (or one like it anyways) and definately NOT worth a credit! (Frankly the receipes weren't worth 2 cents anyways!) Wishing you luck and a good day.
|
|||
|
|||
I"m guessing it also has advertising in it? Cookbooks with advertising for the publishing company are not allowed here because they can't be shipped media rate. |
|||
|
|||
Thank you all! I found the "Report Suspiciou Items Thread" (I don't know how I missed it before I started this thread.) The "cookbooks" I found were all magazines or pamphlets that you could go to the product manufacturer's website and order for free, no strings attached. Calling them a cookbook is a bit of a joke, as they are basically ads for the product, ie Jiffy mixes, but disguised as recipes which require the use of a Jiffy product. In my copy, there is an ad for Jiffy on every few pages. Many of the pamphlets I wouldn't mind having, but I felt that posting them for a credit was a bit decietful, as they are not genuine cookbooks and I would be paying a credit for something I could go also get for free. |
|||
|
|||
The thIng about those booklets is, if they are over 50 pages with no ISBN they can be posted with the 5 digit ISBN. |
|||
|
|||
The key question to the validity of these is whether or not they have 50 pgs. They don't have to have an ISBN if they have 50 pgs, and are a valid item. Whether you can get them free or not is not relavent - Under 50 pages - MUST have a valid 10/13 digit ISBN (And if it doesn't, marking it with the tags as an invalid item is perfectly fine) Over 50 pages - Doesn't have to have an ISBN (an ad for Jiffy in a Jiffy cookbook is not what the PO considers advertising. It says something about an advertisement for itself not counting) |
|||
|
|||
Well, the pamphlets I flagged clearly do not have an ISBN. And the PBS rule on this (found in the help docs) clearly states: Pamphlets/Booklets/leaflets without ISBNs: NO
A pamphlet/booklet WITHOUT an ISBN is unpostable. The reason being: These sometimes contain advertising; members also complain at having to pay a credit for these. Additionally, and perhaps I was not clear in my OP, much of what I found can also be considered a magazine. (They are the 5"x6" sized magazines, often found at the checkout of grocery stores, but instead of articles they are stricktly a recipe magazine.) Per the help docs: http://www.paperbackswap.com/help/search.php?terms=magazine Magazines: NO
|
|||
|
|||
This is the defintion of leaflets and booklets from the HC..
Last Edited on: 2/17/09 6:55 PM ET - Total times edited: 1 |
|||
|
|||
<<an ad for Jiffy in a Jiffy cookbook is not what the PO considers advertising. It says something about an advertisement for itself not counting>> Actually, this isn't quite accurate. The USPS site states that "Media Mail can not contain advertising except for incidental announcements of books.", which makes sense -- it would be reasonable for a book to advertise "be sure and check out book XYZ by this same author". Advertising for Jiffy is a food product, not a book, so it doesn't qualify for Media Mail. So, as others have stated, report it under the suspicious items thread and state why -- it contains advertising for Jiffy. The page number/ISBN issue becomes irrelevant, since it can't be sent Media Mail. Cheers, Catt |
|||
|
|||
Sandra, while you are correct, but many of what I found also fall under the category of Magazine (as I clarified in my previous reply.) Per the help docs: Magazines: NO
|
|||