Not my favorite Amy Clipston book. I found this one really repetitive and predictable. The book drags out the two main problems (Rudy and Laura's relationship and Allen and Laura's relationship) the entire time, with people avoiding their feelings instead of talking things out like adults, and I just couldn't stand that. Also, I really doubt any Amish community would ever let a single man and woman live together for any amount of time, for any reason... That plot point made the book feel unrealistic.