Book Reviews of Songs Without Words

Songs Without Words
Songs Without Words
Author: Ann Packer
ISBN-13: 9780375412813
ISBN-10: 0375412816
Publication Date: 9/4/2007
Pages: 352
Rating:
  • Currently 3.2/5 Stars.
 67

3.2 stars, based on 67 ratings
Publisher: Knopf
Book Type: Hardcover
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

13 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed Songs Without Words on + 113 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 7
I was so disappointed in this book. I loved The Dive from Clausen's Pier, but not this one. I ended up skimming the last 50 pages to get it over with. I felt like she never got to the point and the writing danced around what it was really trying to say. She was also unable to get me emotionally involved with these characters and I didn't care how it ended.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 7 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 5
I found this book to be both engrossing and emotionally challenging to read. The topic of depression is covered very well here, and I found myself getting drawn into the story right from the beginning. I cared about the characters and felt like they could be people I know. Highly recommended Another good book by Ann Packer is 'The Dive From Clausen's Pier'.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 121 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 4
Although I read this book all the way through, I must say that I just didn't âget into itâ that much. I just felt so removed from the characters and, in many ways, not much happened. I was disappointed in this book as I had enjoyed The Dive From Clausen's Pier.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 12 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
This book has such a loose plot it's practically LOST.

If you wanna read something that is pointless and has no real story line or plot or interesting characters, this is for you.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 8 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
This story flows with eloquence. It can be as harrowing as riding the rapids. The characters are beautiful but tragic. The story reflects the good and bad of lifelong friendships. Definitely not the "buddy book". But it may be able to lend insight to relationships of different types.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 38 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Overall, I liked the book. In fact, I liked it better than "The Dive From Clausen's Pier". However, with that said, a lot of the description simply didn't ring true for me. Someone else mentioned that the male characters were written as stereotypical or "stock" men, and I can agree with that assessment to some extent. Brody, Liz's husband, was rarely home due to his high-powered job with his friend's internet security company, yet he still managed to forge a connection to his second child (and only son) Joe.

I kept waiting for a deeper exploration of the pains and myths driving all of these characters. I wanted more backstory on Sarabeth's home and family life--didn't get it. I wanted Sarabeth as well to be a better adult. Pining over the loss of a married boyfriend and mooning over another man who was also married (but looking) had me liking her far less. Everyone in the book (except for a couple of the doctors) seemed to be a pitiful victim of their own inability to act properly.

The ending was completely unsatisfactory. It really did feel contrived, and I was upset with the author for giving us such a tepid resolution.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 218 more book reviews
A lifelong friendship that is pushed to the breaking point. A slow going book and probably my last by this author.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 14 more book reviews
This is the first book I have read by Ann Packer and I was not impressed.....but I will try another. This one never seemed to have a point---or I just didn't get it! I feel like the author left out the important things that I would have liked to have known about her characters. Was not a TOTAL waste of time, just left me wanting....
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 112 more book reviews
For some reason, I couldnt really get into this book.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 217 more book reviews
Personally I enjoyed this book. Yes, the plot is a bit "loose", no there is no defining climax, but that's not what this story is all about. It's the story of a family and how the actions, feelings and behavior of those we love affect us. It's the story of two friends that even though they travel on two different paths, seem to come together and need each other.

For many parents today, this book rings true of our lives. We try to interact with our children, we try to make time for ourselves but we wind up driving through on autopilot and only wake up when something out of the ordinary happens. This story is a reminder of what is really important and how easy it is to overlook that and wallow in the suffering of day to day activities.

Many people have said this book is boring or it wasn't very good, I think that it's all in the readers expectations. I couldn't put this book down. Read the book and decide for yourself.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 636 more book reviews
I really did enjoy this book - although I think I liked her first book better. It was pretty depressing (being mainly about depression...ha, ha). I thought that main friendship was a little lacking - it's not like other friend-books where I am dying to have my friends read them after me. But, I did enjoy it and I'm sure I will continue to watch out for this author.
reviewed Songs Without Words on
What I heard on the first 5 cds (before giving up) was the thinking of 3 emotionally fragile women who need to stop over-analyzing themselves and *do* something other than applying psycho-babble to every single thought and action they experience. The narrator has a low, almost-vocal-fry voice which was beyond irritating. But then, she was probably bored, too.
reviewed Songs Without Words on + 112 more book reviews
I was very disappointed in this book. I could not get into the characters or the story line at all. In fact, I started skimming through just to finish. That seldom happens to me as I can usually find some reason to stick with it. The characters had no depth and I found it hard to figure out what she, the author, was really trying to communicate. A big let down after her first novel.