I absolutely loved this book! It is written with such insight into the culture of the Hmong. It was an eye opener of the best kind - taking the reader into the midst of a medical case involving a very ill Hmong child in a small county hospital in California - language and cultural barriers that the author works to eliminate. Racial tensions, discrimination, miscommunication - the author worked through it and detailed the journey into a very readable, intelligent, thought-provoking piece of work.
Peg D. reviewed The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down : A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures on + 2 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 5
A Hmong child, her American doctors, and the collision of two cultures. Probably one of the best books I have ever read, a non-fiction that reads like a novel. This child is born with epilepsy, and the parents believe her condition is caused by spirits called "dabs", and don't administer her medications properly, if at all. Anne Fadiman is a wonderful writer, and you will be caught up in the drama as well as further understanding the Hmong people and their history. I can't recommend this highly enough.
This book details the clash of two culturs: an immigrant Hmong family and the American medical system as each strives to keep the young daughter who has epilepsy healthy. Very though provoking--it provided the perspective of our medical care through the eyes of another culture. (good information for all health care professionals.) I also learned alot about the Hmong culture, how they were affected by the Vietnam war and how many immigrated to the US. This is not a light reading book; I also had a light-reading book to read so I could alternate between them as my mood dictated. Story plot detailed in other reviews.
This book is required reading for the nursing program I'm in at a college in Sacramento. The title threw me off at first, but after starting this book I was HOOKED! I found the comparison of cultures completely fascinating! It reminded me how easy it is to judge others, when you are unaware of their reasons or background. This book actually helped me view the world in a different light. I have always been interested in other cultures and beliefs, but this book blew me away. It is written beautifully and simply so that you feel as if you are right there. Amazing!
I found this book to consist of two stories. The first is the clash between the Hmong family and the US medical establishment in Merced, CA. The second story is the history of the Hmong peoples. I found the first story the most interesting and quickest to read. The second story is slower to read and more bogged down in facts. The second story, however, helps us to understand why the Hmong are here and what their culture is about. An interesting read and reflection on Hmong culture vs American culture.
Amanda P. (phillyjane) reviewed The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down : A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures on
Helpful Score: 2
I had to read this book for college, and it was - hands down - my favorite piece of assigned literature. I read it through a second time completely of my own free will. The frustrating conflict between culture and medicine is masterfully portrayed. This book was very thought provoking, and caused me to experience a teeter-totter of emotions. One moment I was cursing the doctors for not listening, the next chapter I was exasperated with the family for their lack of understanding. The only parts of the book I didn't care for were the "history of Laos" chapters - while they provided insight to the Hmong culture; they seemed very dry in comparison to the rest of the book.
If you are involved in the health care field in any way, this book is a must read.
Honestly, even if you don't work in health care, I can't imagine you'd regret reading this book. I loved it.
An incredibly fascinating account of culture clash between Western medicine and the belief system of the Hmong people of Laos. It deals specifically with a Hmong child who has severe epilepsy, but it also goes into depth about Hmong history and beliefs. This is neither a fast or light read, but if you have the motivation you will learn a great deal.
This book is an amazing look at how cultures can clash and the impact it has on real, live people. This is not a theoretical look at the the need for a multicultural perspective, but a heart-breaking story of how refusal to acknowledge and appreciate difference can change lives. It taught me that by appreciating difference, I can also change lives, but in a good way.
This book will now be required reading in a course I teach called "Introduction to Human Services."
This book was a suggested reading at the back of a textbook. I found it to be the most interesting book, I enjoyed every minute realizing how people from different cultures will see things so vastly differently. For those of us who want to communicate more effectively with people groups other than our own, this is a book that will touch your heart and mind. It is a very touching book and one I recommend even if you just want a great, touching true story to read.
crackabook reviewed The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down : A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures on
Helpful Score: 1
Who are the Hmong, where do they come from and why are they here in America? What are their beliefs/culture? This and more is covered by the author as you follow the struggle of one loving family in a new and strange land trying to survive and raise their children. Non-fiction, I recommend this read to enlighten you to your new neighbors.
Hard to read in some places. Bounces from place to place without a chronology. It is a fascinating story about medicine and cultural differences. I learned a lot about the Hmong people, a group I had never heard of before.
Misty R. reviewed The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down : A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures on
I loved this book. I learned so much about the Hmong culture by reading this book. I also learned about how difficult it can be to have a sick child when you have a cultural barrier. I have a daughter who has epilepsy and there was so much I took for granted about her health care. I grew to love the family, the Hmong culture and history, and the writing style. Worth the read. I recommended it out to a friend to read as soon as I finished reading it.
This book is the story of a family with a sick child. This family immigrated from Laos after the Vietnam war. It is also, if not more so, the story of those who come to this country and do not understand our culture, and those who meet their medical, spiritual, physical needs who do not understand or try to understand their cultures.
This book was required reading for my Cultural Anthropology class, and I'm glad I read it.
The book revolves around Lia, a Hmong child with severe epilepsy, and how her parents and doctors struggle to help her. Her parents are very traditional in Hmong terms and percieve Lia's seizures as a sign that Lia is able to see into the spirit world. This brings them a great sense of pride. However, being in America, doctors know how serious the situation is and try to convince the parents.
The parents only want what is best for their daughter, but, in there minds, where American doctors raise red flags, they struggle on what that is.
The Spirit Cathes You is a great book that really makes you think about culture as the "outline" of how we perceive the world.
This book explores the clash between a small county hospital in California and a refugee family from Laos over the care of Lia Lee, a Hmong child diagnosed with severe epilepsy. Lia's parents and the doctors both want what's best for Lia, but the lack of understanding between them leads to tragedy. Anne Fadiman's compassionate account of this cultural impasse is literary journalism at it's best. ( From the book jacket)