Book Reviews of War for the Oaks

War for the Oaks
War for the Oaks
Author: Emma Bull
ISBN-13: 9780441870738
ISBN-10: 0441870732
Publication Date: 6/1996
Pages: 309
Edition: Reissue
Rating:
  • Currently 4.4/5 Stars.
 31

4.4 stars, based on 31 ratings
Publisher: Ace Books
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

15 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed War for the Oaks on + 91 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Classic urban fantasy. Musicians, warring faerie factions, big fun.
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 404 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
This is a beautifully written book that is both poetical and fantastical. liked the mix of music and magic. All the characters are well defined, and I especially liked Eddi, Willy and the phouka.
reviewed War for the Oaks on
Helpful Score: 1
Really great fantasy read, one of my favorites. This is a story about a very normal woman having a bad day who gets stuck in the middle of a supernatural war. Never boring.
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 23 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
An urban fairytale set in downtown Minneapolis. At once edgy and lyrical, this is a novel that defies its genre.
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 47 more book reviews
A modern fantasy, enjoyable
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 40 more book reviews
The best book I've read in a while! Wonderful and clever wrighting. This novel was originally released in 1987, and the eights pop culture vibe (especially the fashion) is a lot of fun.
reviewed War for the Oaks on
Good urban fantasy.
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 300 more book reviews
I found this book difficult to get into, so I ended up not finishing it. I don't know if it was the characters or the storyline but it wasn't for me.
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 2 more book reviews
Fun contemporary fantasy novel about a faerie war in St. Louis that entangles a young woman. Good, light read, and chock full of 80'sness (seriously, this book is bursting with the 80s)
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 8 more book reviews
While the context is definitely dated (late '80s), this book is well-written and, I'm sure, went a long way toward defining an entire genre. Worth the time for fans of urban fantasy/alternate realities.
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 14 more book reviews
This book was so cheesy and had some weird racial scenes, but it kept my interest. I enjoyed the faeries. And how can you not fall in love with a guy who looks like Prince and can turn into a dog? (I love dogs.)
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 6 more book reviews
Sharp, lucid and full of beautiful phrases, War for the Oaks is the sort of book you read and never forget. The best urban fantasy ever written, in my opinion.
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 71 more book reviews
very good
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 15 more book reviews
a sci fi fantasy with music and dark elves
reviewed War for the Oaks on + 31 more book reviews
I'm somewhere in between with this book.

First, the main girl, Eddi. She wasn't a blushing, stammering, stupid airhead; so far, so good. On occasion, she even had a bit of spine; yay! She was not, however, a particularly strong character, nor was she a memorable one. She was on the somewhat likeable end of tolerable.

The phouka was an amusing character, but his style of speech jarred me. It was for old-fashioned sounding, and maybe it was just because he got the most screen time in the book, but he seemed to speak in much more flowery way then any of the other character, including the other fey. At least his entertaining mood swings and magical wardrobe made up for that.

This book had romance, which I wasnt thrilled about. I still cant say that I enjoyed the romantic aspect, but at least it sorta made sense, so I could at least tolerate it in a necessary evil sort of way. Sounds cynical, I know, but considering how much I hate romance in books, this is actually high praise.

A lot of the plot, the action especially, felt lacking. First, a lot of it was predictable. Whether that was this authors fault or the fault of later authors that may have copied her, I dont know. Second, for a book that claims to be about a faerie war, theres a noticeable lack of fighting. Theres one horse-and-sword battle that lasts about one chapter, one hostage rescue, and a battle of the bands. What? The battles are more of a side note, the focus being on music and bands.

So, not bad, but not amazing and not quite my thing.