15 member(s) found this review helpful.
Up to the fall of the World Trade Center in the last 50 or so pages, this book blew my mind. Chronicling the lives of three college friends now thirty and living in New York and struggling to come to terms with their own limitations while at the same time trying to change the world in some way, Messud's language is brilliant. Simultaneously, there exists a sense of entitlement drawn from their ivy league educations...urban revolutionists without a revolution. In the post-9/11 chapters however, it seems hurried in a wholly unsettling way. Though none of the characters are completely unlikeable, none of them are really all that likable either; their entitlement becomes distracting while their ambition is all but abandoned.
11 member(s) found this review helpful.
I excitedly picked up this book, looking forward to an enjoyable read about characters in the same time in life as myself. Unfortunately, I found myself continuing to read this novel and waiting: waiting for something, anything that might create some movement within the stories. I waited all the way to the last page and never found what I was looking for.

Aimie Z. (
aylaanne) wrote on 2/28/2008...
7 member(s) found this review helpful.
My mother-in-law gave me this book when I told her I was spending a lot of time reading with the baby at my breast. Like a lot of novels, it had acclaims printed all over it, and three full pages of critic quotes praising it at the beginning. However, for me it failed to deliver. The beginning kind of dragged, for one. Also, the author tended to write her character's thoughts in a stream-of-consciousness format that was incredibly hard to follow. She would start a sentance with a thought, then interrupt it with a second thought, then a third, then maybe a fourth, and then finish up the first thought. It was very hard to follow. Also, her characters were, for the most part, incredibly hard to sympathize with. The main characters were in their 30s and selfish, entitled, and bratty. I wanted to smack the lot of them. I think the reason the book got such rave reviews is that it takes place in 2001, from March to November, and the climax is the September 11th attacks. I had to work hard to get myself in a pre-9/11 mindset for the beginning of the book, and when the attacks came I was as shocked as the characters. Without including the horror of September 11th, her book would have been a tremendous disappointment. With it, the story was almost redeemed. Almost. I think the melancholy nature of many of the characters through the book affected my own post-partum mood.
6 member(s) found this review helpful.
This was not one of my favorite selections. I thought it rambled on in many places and found myself skimming through pages to get to the point. Just not my cup of tea.
6 member(s) found this review helpful.
This book started off intresting but turned dull towards the middle. I had a hard time finishing it and it wasn't worth my time.
5 member(s) found this review helpful.
I tried to like this book, but the style it was written in was so over the top. I felt like the author was purposefully using elaborate words and very long sentences to make the reader feel....well....stupid.
The story dragged a bit and could have been told much more clearly.
4 member(s) found this review helpful.
I did not like this book. It was depressing, draining, and just a waste of time when there are so many other good books out there to read. There were touches of John Updike but something about it did not flow. I found the rave reviews to be over the top.
3 member(s) found this review helpful.
Definitely a clever novel but one that, to me, begs the question - can't a serious novel be enjoyable to read? I'm well-read but the language had me reading with a dictionary at hand. The book seemed as self-absorbed as the characters it chronicled. I'm sorry, I know this book is wildly popular, but I was glad to be done with it.

Jane H. (
pip) wrote on 7/24/2008...
2 member(s) found this review helpful.
Had a hard time getting into this book, but my Mom enjoyed it.