I was expecting a Harry Potter knockoff and got something surprisingly different. The characters are well-drawn, if only occasionally one-dimensional, but the villains, Charlie's great aunts and paternal grandmother, are so ridiculously nasty you will sometimes wonder why anyone puts up with them at all. These read fast and will entertain younger readers very well. Adults may have a harder time not projecting into the story how they'd get rid of the nasty aunts and grandmother...
patticom - Apo, AE wrote on 6/28/2008...
Even as an adult, I enjoyed this book for a little fun, light reading. The first few chapters were difficult to get through, because there are definitely a LOT of similarities to Harry Potter. However, if you can stick with it, by the middle of the book you will start forgetting about the similarities and begin accepting Charlie's world as its own special place!
Great book. 5th grade and up (or advanced 4th)
Charlie doesn't want to believe it. He can hear people talking in photographs. What' happening to him? Why now?
Charlie doesn't want to believe it.
He can hear people talking in photographs.
What's happening to him?
Why Now?
The mysterious and magical powers of the Red King have been passed down through his descendants. These gifts, some evil and some good, turn up unexpectedly in someone who has no idea where they came from. This is what happened to Charlie Bone....
Charlie doesn't want to believe it when he discovers that he can hear the thoughts of people in photographs. But his horrible aunts are delighted-- it means that he is one of the chosen and must attend the Bloor's Academy for gifted children. Once there, Charlie realizes that some of his classmates have equally mysterious powers, and soon Charlie is involved in uncovering the mysterious past of one of them.
It's a great book for children.
Another of my son's books. This was a great first book of a series.
Your Harry Potter fans will love this. Charlie can hear people talking in photographs, and his aunts are delighted because this means he is one of the "chosen". Great for upper elementary or junior high kids.
The mysterious and magical powers of the Red King have been passed down through his descendents. These gifts, some evil and some good, turn up unexpectedly in someone who has no idea where they came from. This is what happened to Charlie Bone...
Charlie doesn't want to believe it when he discovers that he can hear the thoughts of pepole in photographs. But his horrible aunts are delighted -- it means that he is one of the chosen and must attend the Bloor's Acedemy for gifted children. Once there, Charlie realizes that some of his classmates have equally mysterious powers, and soon Charlie is involved in uncovering the mysterious past of one of them.
Charlie doesn't want to believe it. He can hear people talking in photographs. What's happening to him? Why now? The mysterious and magical powers of the Red King have been passed down through his descendants. These gifts, some evil and some good, turn up unexpectedly in someone who has no idea where they came from. This is what happened to Charlie Bone...Charlie doesn't want to believe it when he discovers that he can hear the thoughts of people in photographs. But his horrible aunts are delighted - it means that he is one of the chosen and must attend the Bloor's Academy for gifted children. Once there, Charlie realizes that some of his classmages have equally mysterious powers, and soon Charlie is involved in uncovering the mysterious past of one of them.