1 member(s) found this review helpful.
Jack and melli i found to be boring characters. . But i truly loved Baralis and Maybors feuding and all the chaos within those two! they were truly interesting.
I finished the book just to see what happened with those two! ahhaha i felt like Jack and Melli were under developed as characters, and often times boring.
all in all the book is not a bad read, its a different kind of fantasy, not as dark as her new series, or what i prefer but i would reccomend this book only to people that enjoy certain typed of fantasies, its really a book that you will either find boring or really love. But i suggest you reade it and see for yourself. . .A few of the characters alone are well worth the read.. .
I give the book 3 out of 5
1 member(s) found this review helpful.
Excellent series with all the ingredients - seldom cookie-cutter, but a little typical - boy with secret talent, love interest/romance, ancient, mysterious teacher to train boy's talent, boy defeats older, wiser, evil enemy. BUT even though it's a little patterned/stereotypical, this book is fun, interesting, and very well written. Jones works in enough creativity and newness to make it well worth reading.
1 member(s) found this review helpful.
For a debut, this is nice.Politics abound with plots everywhere.Nasty villian, clueless hero and very funny interludes from some drunk guards.lenghty pages, but easily read.first of a trilogy.

Scott K. (
squid1) wrote on 8/19/2005...
1 member(s) found this review helpful.
Book 1 of a trilogy. Good Fantasy, good enough to make me buy the other 2 books anyway.