Facebook
Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 
Want fewer ads?

Search - The Hidden Life of Deer: Lessons from the Natural World

The Hidden Life of Deer: Lessons from the Natural World
The Hidden Life of Deer Lessons from the Natural World
Author: Elizabeth Marshall Thomas
The animal kingdom operates by ancient rules, and the deer in our woods and backyards can teach us many of them—but only if we take the time to notice. In the fall of 2007 in southern New Hampshire, the acorn crop failed and the animals who depended on it faced starvation. Elizabeth Marshall Thomas began leaving food in small piles aroun...  more »
ISBN-13: 9780061792113
ISBN-10: 006179211X
Publication Date: 11/1/2010
Pages: 256
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
 2

2.5 stars, based on 2 ratings
Publisher: Harper Perennial
Book Type: Paperback
Members Wishing: 4
Reviews: Member | Amazon | Write a Review
Read All 1 Book Reviews of "The Hidden Life of Deer Lessons from the Natural World"

Please Log in to Rate these Book Reviews

stormslegacy avatar reviewed The Hidden Life of Deer: Lessons from the Natural World on + 3 more book reviews
As someone who has taken classes in animal biology and intelligence to earn a degree in biology, I was excited to see a book that appeared to be a study of animal behavior. Now, I'm not a believer that science need only be performed by those with degrees or laboratories--anyone with observational skills can be a scientist. That said, Elizabeth Marshall Thomas is not.

She writes about how she attracted the deer for the winter by feeding them corn--she goes on for a whole chapter about why she felt that the laws were BS and that she was just supplementing their diet, saving them from a winter of starvation. If she read up on the subject a bit she'd find that ruminates that eat corn have the acidity in their rumen go up and kill off the good bacteria causing difficulty digesting food and sickness. It's why we pump our cows full of antibiotics and other chemicals during finishing when they are on a high-corn diet. In other words--she not only was harming them but is encouraging others to harm them as well. Deer aren't meant to eat high carbohydrate feed in the winter--their system is meant for fibrous stems and grasses at that time. Please don't follow her lead!

She also doesn't observe so much as come up with her own random hypotheses without actually testing them in any way through her observations. She just gets excited and sees any little details as confirming whatever she believes. At one point in the books she feels she has proof that she could "thought-speak" to one of them. She's very emotional, and I think the biggest example of her misinterpretation of animal behavior is when she thought that the small male deer were claiming a larger buck's territory after he was shot was them "honoring his spirit." No lady, it's very obvious that these animals were taking advantage of the fact that they could look larger than they really are by running their scent all over the areas where he rubbed his antlers higher then they could actually reach.

I would not be so annoyed if this book were touted about what it is--a misguided animal lover who likes to come up with stories about the animals in her backyard. If this were a work of fiction I'd rank it 4 stars--as a book that pretends to be science I'm rating it 1. You will learn nothing of worth here.


Genres:

Want fewer ads?