The Sunday Philosophy Club (Isabel Dalhousie, Bk 1) (Audio Cassette) (Unabridged)
The Sunday Philosophy Club - Isabel Dalhousie, Bk 1 - Audio Cassette - Unabridged Author:Alexander McCall Smith, Davina Porter (Narrator) Isabel Dalhousie is a philosopher by training, and an amateur sleuth by choice. When a young man falls from a balcony to his death, Isabel does not believe it was an accident. Plunging deep into the shady business community of Edinburgh, she is determined to root out the truth. — Unabridged: 5 Cassette Tapes, Running Time: 7 hours, Narrator... more »: Davina Porter« less
Patricia S. reviewed The Sunday Philosophy Club (Isabel Dalhousie, Bk 1) (Audio Cassette) (Unabridged) on
Helpful Score: 6
I ADORE the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series by this author. This series, however, is slow and pendantic and self-rightous. it is as if he is trying to be "intellectual". This has none of the joy or lightheartedness of the No 1 Ladies Detective Agency books.
I'll post it anyway. Someone might want to read it. Don't know why....
I'm a little more than halfway through this book as I started writing this review. The pages so far have been like stone...very hard to turn. I started reading this series because I loved the writer's style in the No. 1 Ladies’ Detective series which I found to be rich and eloquent. This, however, I find flat and verbose. - like poorly a cooked pot roast in thin gravy - very hard to chew and swallow. Isabel Dalhouse is no Mme Precious Ramotswe; in fact, every character so far is dull and uninteresting; the setting is uninteresting; there is nothing to like or dislike about the people or the place. Whereas Mme Ramotswe’s -ruminations were honey filled pears of wisdom, Isabel's musings - the fluff filler of the book - were wordy and academic which translate as boring and pretentious. The thoughts seem detached from the character as if it is the writer's own musings (which of course it is) and not the character's ( which is what the writer should make us believe).
Well, I did finish the book, just because I forced myself to do so, and it did not get any easier or enjoyable.
I did not enjoy this one from McCall Smith quite as much as the "The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency" novels; there is a certain amount of philosophical meanderings, which somehow detract from the detective aspect. However, it is a very readable mystery story, set in Scotland.
It took me few false starts to read the NO 1 Ladies Detective agency. For that reason, I decided to approach this book the same way, that it may take me time to GET the book and the speech patterns. This is a good book if you can accept it for what it is and for what it is not. It is not the NO 1 Ladies Detective Agency. It should not be expected to be that book or that character just because it is the same author. It is a great story that asks some Philosophical question throughout since the Main character is a Philosophy editor. As Americans, we may find some of the content unfamiliar. He isnt writting Fluff. He uses big SAT words. I found it thought provoking, useful, and entertaining. I am looking forward to reading the next book.
What can I say..either you are a McCall Smith fan or you aren't. I am.Isabel Dalhousie is the Edinburgh version of MMa Ramotswe in Botswana.She has maybe just a touch of Stephanie Plum thrown in There are now 2 more books in this series, which I do not have..."Friends,Lovers, Chocolate" and "The Right Attitude to Rain."
With all of the No.1 Detective Agency fans I thought this book would be long gone!
The first in an Isabel Dalhousie mystery series. Well read. Alexander McCall Smith's writing is for those of us who enjoy character as it is revealed through the minutia of daily life. There is humor and a mystery - but no real action and adventure. A cozy.
Isabel Dalhousie is a philospher by training, and an amateur sleuth by choice. When a young man falls from a balcony to his death, Isabel's curiousity is aroused. She does not believe the fall was an accident, and she is determined to root out the truth. With a little help from some friends, Isabel plunges deep into the shady business community of Edinburgh to find some answers. I love Alexander McCall Smith's "The No. 1 Ladies Detective" series so I anticipated this series to be of the same caliber. It wasn't. It didn't have a central character I could identify with (The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency" central character, "Precious Ramotswe, Botswana detective that is traditionally built" is someone I have much in common and would love to live next door to and have tea with even though she is a far cry from my own Eastern European roots, Midwest born and raised, lived in remote areas of developing countries, and finally settling in the Old South to raise my family).