Book Reviews of Auschwitz: True Tales from a Grotesque Land

Auschwitz: True Tales from a Grotesque Land
Auschwitz True Tales from a Grotesque Land
Author: Sara Nomberg-Przuytyk, Roslyn Hirsch, Eli Pfefferkorn, David H Hirsch
ISBN-13: 9780807841600
ISBN-10: 0807841609
Publication Date: 1985
Pages: 181
Rating:
  • Currently 4.7/5 Stars.
 10

4.7 stars, based on 10 ratings
Publisher: University of North Carolina Press
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

6 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed Auschwitz: True Tales from a Grotesque Land on + 336 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Again, seeing that this is apparently targeting the YA audience, I just can't agree. He/She would have to be a very mature young adult before I handed them this book. Maybe I'm not giving young people enough credit but the stories included here I wouldn't want my daughter reading at a young age. I'm 100% for knowledge, most especially of anything like this, but one has to be able to process the information being learned or no good will come from it, only pain, if anything.
That being said, this is outstanding. It really is. The reason I'm giving it four stars instead of five is personal. I'm not much of a short story person. I think, as much as I "liked" reading this, that I'd have much more enjoyed a whole sequencial book by Nomberg-Przytyk.
One thing I did not like - the afterword. I felt like I was being sold the author, her writing, and this book. Anyone that read the book before the afterword (as it should be) would already be sold on all three things IMO. And if not, the afterword isn't going to change anything. I don't like anything being pushed on me and the afterword really should be cut out of here. Scratch that - it shouldn't be cut out. There are a number of good points brought up, a lot of which a reader may not think about on their own. What should be cut out are the selling points. It takes away from the book in a horrible, horrible way.
I can't even recommend skipping this afterword altogether because of the parts I mentioned above. I would only suggest to be aware and not fall into the sales pitch. If you got something from the book it won't be because of the afterword.
It is said, in the afterword no less, that Nomberg-Przytyk writes without absolute memory on some subjects. This had be skeptical at first but after reading one of the "good parts" in the afterword I changed my mind. I do believe that there is a good arguement for this type of writing. In one story the author writes about the first time she hears the word "organize" in the "Aushwitz term". Instead of organize meaning 'forming as or into a whole', in the Aushwitz sense organize means to steal to survive. Whether that means stealing food to trade for cigarettes to trade for a "good" job or something else, there is a new meaning for an old word.
The point of bringing this up is because it's said that it's unlikely this was the first time she heard the word. After all, that one word was probably spoken dozens and dozens of times in a day since "organizing" was so very important to survival.
Now, when I'm reading non-fiction I tend to want it exactly as it happened. I want to believe in that because without, is it really non-fiction in the strictest sense? Here I think yes. I don't think I'd care for this in many books but it works here and that's a great feat for Nomberg-Przytyk.
reviewed Auschwitz: True Tales from a Grotesque Land on + 301 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
This book is an eye opener. It shows what human beings will do just to survive. I always heard about the horrors committed on the prisoners by soldiers but not about the prisoners turning on each other. I was able to see all sides in this book. There were evil SS men and yet there were ones that showed compassion. There were prisoners that would beat and starve other prisoners and ones who stuck together through all. A wonderful read but I would have liked to know more at the end though... more of her life after the war was over.
reviewed Auschwitz: True Tales from a Grotesque Land on + 97 more book reviews
This is probably the most mentally difficult book I have ever read about the Holocaust. The author was a prisoner in Auschwitz from 1943 until January 1945 when the Russian army advanced into Poland and the Nazis forced the prisoners to march. Sara is able to tell these horrible stories from her time there in a way that makes you truly understand the mental challenge of survival in Auschwitz. She is an expert story teller and worked in the infirmary. She gives many firsthand accounts of Josef Mengele and his brutality hidden behind a handsome face. She also delves into the moral issues of how prisoners were able to deal with the daily sight of death and continue to maintain an attitude that allowed them to survive. She touches on all of the 'lore' of Auschwitz but manages to somehow humanize the unthinkable atrocities.

This book will draw you into the nightmare that was Auschwitz. It is likely you will not be able to put it down once you begin. If you have a strong constitution and are interested in knowing more about life inside Auschwitz I recommend this book. The author is a skillful storyteller.
reviewed Auschwitz: True Tales from a Grotesque Land on + 76 more book reviews
Difficult to read, but highly informative. The details of concentration camp life are heartbreaking.
reviewed Auschwitz: True Tales from a Grotesque Land on + 200 more book reviews
This is an incredible first person account of the author's period of imprisonment in Auschwitz. She was jailed as a political prisoner and worked in the camp infirmary to survive. She describes her own day to day struggles to survive, illnesses, bartering for food, escaping the selection for the gas chamber, her interactions with the "Doctor of Death" Joseph Mengele and, finally, her return to her Polish homeland at the end of the war. A gripping narrative, highly recommended.
reviewed Auschwitz: True Tales from a Grotesque Land on + 195 more book reviews
much to learn in this book about aushwitz and the range of human
behavior