Pseudonym
Her pseudonym recalls the 1928 novel
Belle de jour by Joseph Kessel and the 1967 film of the same name starring Catherine Deneuve, directed by Luis Buñuel. In French "Belle de Jour" is an expression translating literally as "beauty of [the] day," as opposed to "femme de nuit" or "belle de nuit," women of the night (common references to prostitutes). "Belle de jour" is a play on the phrase, possibly a reference to the daylight
rendezvous made by some call girls, including Belle de Jour herself.
There was speculation in the media for several years as to the real identity of the author, whether Belle really was a call girl and whether her diary entries were based on fact or entirely fictitious. Guesses as to who Belle was ranged from Rowan Pelling to Toby Young according to
The Telegraph.
According to
The Guardian a fellow British blogger guessed her identity in 2003 but kept it secret. He made a page on his blog containing the googlewhack of Belle de Jour and Brooke Magnanti that allowed him to see if anyone googled the two names. In 2009 he identified IP addresses originating from Associated Newspapers that had accessed the page at which point he contacted Brooke to alert her.
Revelation of identity
On 15 November 2009,
The Sunday Times revealed in an interview that Dr Brooke Magnanti is the author's real name; Magnanti was 34 years of age at the time.
The Guardians Paul Gallagher described it as the revelation of "one of the best kept literary secrets of the decade".
The Daily Telegraphs Stephen Adams said it had been "the new millennium's equivalent of the 1980s' search for the golden hare". Such was the nature of the secret, Magnanti's work colleagues did not know until one month before she went public, her publishers had been unaware of her true identity until the previous week and her parents found out on that weekend. After signing her first book deal and starting writing articles for newspapers, only two other people were aware of her identity, her agent Patrick Walsh and her accountant, who handled the financial transactions via a shell corporation. Magnanti commented that she had thought a former boyfriend was on the verge of outing her.
Writing on her blog on the day of the revelation, Magnanti stated:
It feels so much better on this side. Not to have to tell lies, hide things from the people I care about. To be able to defend what my experience of sex work is like to all the sceptics and doubters. Anonymity had a purpose then - it will always have a reason to exist, for writers whose work is too damaging or too controversial to put their names on
A spokesperson for Bristol University stated, "This aspect of Dr Magnanti's past is not relevant to her current role at the university", while her publisher said, "It's a courageous decision for Belle de Jour to come forward with her true identity and we support her decision to do so".
Since unveiling her identity as Belle de Jour, images of Brooke Magnanti appeared in several national newspapers.