Helpful Score: 3
This is a beautifully written story that explores aspects of motherhood that people are uncomfortable discussing --- frustration, boredom, uncertainty about where you fit into your own life after children come along. It is not dark or morbid, but instead is honest and hopeful despite the difficult subject.
Helpful Score: 3
Honestly, this one left me rather confused.
I enjoyed the writing style, and the storyline was good. The event that Elizabeth blocked out for so long, and finally becomes obsessed with remembering, is a heartbreaking one.
My biggest problem was that there was really no explanation for why she had physical ailments that led to her remembering the past in the first place.
Overall, BETWEEN HERE AND APRIL is a decent read, but it wasn't all that remarkable.
I enjoyed the writing style, and the storyline was good. The event that Elizabeth blocked out for so long, and finally becomes obsessed with remembering, is a heartbreaking one.
My biggest problem was that there was really no explanation for why she had physical ailments that led to her remembering the past in the first place.
Overall, BETWEEN HERE AND APRIL is a decent read, but it wasn't all that remarkable.
Helpful Score: 1
The central charater in this novel is Elizabeth Burns, a journalist and a mother, who is trying desperately to manage the demands and desires of both. Frustrated both with the demands of her home life, as well as with the path her career has taken, Elizabeth tries to revitalize both by investigating the murder of her elementary school best friend, April. April mysteriously disappeared from school in first grade, and it was never entirely clear to 6 year-old Elizabeth precisely what had happened. When Elizabeth the adult and mother discovers that April was killed, along with her sister, by her mother in a murder-suicide, she turns her investigation to what could have April's mother to take her own life and those of her children. Into this story is woven a narrative of Elizabeth's feelings on her family and career. She has made significant sacrifices as a journalist, her marriage has problems, and she never feels quite adequate as a mother. Bouncing betwen these two narratives, Kogan shows how Elizabeth's investigation of April's death forces her to think seriously about her own family and career problems. Though the two clearly intersect, this book can be considered two parallel stories involving the same characters. The mystery story- what happened to April- I found to be far more satisfying than the family narrative. The investigation of April's death reads like a fast-paced mystery, and I was gripped to find out what would happen next. It allows Kogan to engage difficult problems, like post-partum depression, and in many ways, April's desperate mother is the most complicated character in this book, The family narrative I found far less satisfying. Elizabeth's problems are common ones, and this novel really did not offer any sort of new perspective or insight. I found this book hard to put down because I was extremely engaged in the mystery of April's murder, but found it somewhat difficult to get through other parts of the book.
I think this could have been a great story if the author had developed the story line in greater detail. Like the other members who have reviewed this book, I also found the story of the mother the most fascinating part and reading the interaction with the therapist was very good. I didn't care for the main character and while I'm usually very engaged in a good story, I couldn't even finish this one. I just didn't care that much. Halfway through I decided to move on to something I could get excited about.
I loved this book. I didn't want it to end. As soon as I finished it I ordered her memoir about her real-life experiences as a photo-journalist.
I very much enjoyed this book. The author opens a little talked about and still somewhat unaccepted condition among mothers. As a woman that has been there and still is, it was a difficult and yet comforting book to read. The author has opened the door to more discussion and better understanding.
