Helpful Score: 4
A fresh, thoughtful spin on the well-worn fantasy of inhabiting another body, this offbeat debut borrows the cast of A Midsummer Night's Dream and submits them to a very 1990s enchantment. On midsummer night?June 21?39-year-old Katharine Ashley dies of a heart attack in Northern California. The mother of two, whose worldliness consists of having seen the film Woodstock five times in 1970, wakes up a year after her death on a squalid bathroom floor in L.A. She finds herself trapped in the drug- and alcohol-dependent body?and in the unhappy family?of 22-year-old photographer and all-around gilded youth Thisby Bennett. Without any of the discomfiture one might expect in such sitcom circumstances, Katharine navigates Thisby's world, which includes a harelipped sister named Quince and an all-too-attractive brother called Puck. Determined to save everyone (Quince, Puck, her own children and Thisby herself), Katharine discovers much about the temptations and risks of mothering and second chances. It doesn't matter whether this is "a three-second dream before she really dies" or a wonderfully believable wake-up-as-someone-else. The more Shakespeare (and Fawlty Towers and Sesame Street) one knows, the more pleasurable it is to read this crisply written, wry and intelligent book; yet even the reader who falls far short of Doud's knowledge of the Bard will appreciate the emotional resonance of the Katharine/Thisby identity struggle.
Helpful Score: 3
This was a fascinating read. The pace is nice and I found myself able to read it in only a couple of sittings, despite little time on my part to actually sit and read. If you love Shakespeare, you'll enjoy the tie-ins for character names, some plot points, and one family's common interest.
The subject matter is fanciful and at the same time stark. Nothing is recycled here...nearly all the concepts are fresh, original and compelling.
The subject matter is fanciful and at the same time stark. Nothing is recycled here...nearly all the concepts are fresh, original and compelling.
Helpful Score: 2
Good idea for a story, but a little slow for my taste.
Helpful Score: 2
Very interesting read. Makes you think that is for sure!
