Book Reviews of The Dumb Shall Sing (Mystery of Colonial Times)

The Dumb Shall Sing (Mystery of Colonial Times)
The Dumb Shall Sing - Mystery of Colonial Times
Author: Stephen Lewis
ISBN-13: 9780425169971
ISBN-10: 0425169979
Publication Date: 8/1/1999
Pages: 272
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.

3.5 stars, based on 15 ratings
Publisher: Berkley
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

4 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed The Dumb Shall Sing (Mystery of Colonial Times) on + 121 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 4
First book in a series taking place in 17th century New England. Catherine Williams is a 50-ish widow, a midwife, wealthy and respected who with the aid of a Pequot Indian she saves from execution investigates the death of an infant. The lead character is a strong woman, uncharacteristic for the Colonial times and the book appears historically correct in setting and tone.
reviewed The Dumb Shall Sing (Mystery of Colonial Times) on + 1605 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
First Line: The sloop Good Hope, its crowned lion figurehead pointing to the sea, rode the outgoing tide past the mouth of Newbury Bay toward deeper waters whose color changed from light blue near shore to an almost midnight black.

We first see wealthy widow Catherine Williams on board the Good Hope. It's New England in 1638. The Pequot War has ended, and all the Pequot leaders are ready for "justice" on deck. Since the agreement the Puritan leaders of Newbury made was with Catherine's deceased husband, they think they can conveniently forget about it. Catherine deems otherwise and manages to save the life of one of the leaders, Massaquoit, who will now live with her.

Catherine is a well-respected midwife and healer in the community. When a healthy baby she recently delivered dies, she is called upon to testify. The baby's mother is struck dumb with grief, and the father accuses both Catherine and his Irish Catholic maid of having had part in the infant's demise. Catherine believes the maid to be innocent, "guilty" only of being Catholic, and she begins to work to find the real reason for the baby's death.

Lewis uses setting and characterization to good effect in this first book in the series. Seventeenth- century New England comes to life, and Catherine and Massaquoit make a good team of investigators. The only weakness I found in the book was that it was glaringly obvious to me what had happened to the baby. That one flaw aside, I found The Dumb Shall Sing to be a strong start to the series, which to date only contains three books. I'll be looking for the other two, The Blind in Darkness and The Sea Hath Spoken. Strong female characters in this time period should not be passed by!
reviewed The Dumb Shall Sing (Mystery of Colonial Times) on + 59 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Interesting book. Gives you an idea of the lives of the early Puritans.
reviewed The Dumb Shall Sing (Mystery of Colonial Times) on + 36 more book reviews
This is a historical mystery, set in colonial New England widow and midwife doesn't suffer fools gladly which of course in a small New England village in Colonial times, there are plenty of them, Catherine Williams loses the love of her life, her husband, however he does leave her wealthy. First Catherine takes in a Native American who was enslaved and sets him free to work for her, then an infant dies and an Irish Catholic servant who was working for the family is blamed since being a Catholic, she falls prey to the religious prejudices and superstitions. The widow Williams doesn't believe that the girl is responsible but if she doesn't clear the girl"s name, the villagers will hang the girl. This was a wonderful story, you have to like Catherine Willows, the fact that she's wealthy is probably the one thing that protects her from the villagers whims but for a wealthy woman, she is very down to earth and willing to help.