Book Reviews of Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1)

Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1)
Earthly Joys - Earthly Joys, Bk 1
Author: Philippa Gregory
The Market's bargain prices are even better for Paperbackswap club members!
Retail Price: $16.99
Buy New (Paperback): $13.29 (save 21%) or
Become a PBS member and pay $9.39+1 PBS book credit (save 44%)
ISBN-13: 9780743272520
ISBN-10: 0743272528
Publication Date: 5/24/2005
Pages: 528
Rating:
  • Currently 3.4/5 Stars.
 212

3.4 stars, based on 212 ratings
Publisher: Touchstone
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

22 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 32 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 8
Very enjoyable book especially for those who love history as there is a great deal of historical detail. According to the New York Times Book Review, "This tale of forbidden love set against the turmoil of a country in chaos makes for both intelligent and satisfying reading" The "forbidden love" mentioned in this quote is a male/male love affair by the way so if you find that theme offensive you may not want this book. That love affair is actually a fairly small part of the plot of this book.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on
Helpful Score: 5
Interesting historical fiction, but not one of my favorite of Gregory's stories. It was well written, I just did not empathize with the protagonist, John Trandescant, until well into the story, which made it a little harder for me to get into. I did not understand his unquestioning views and acceptance of some things that seemed very unfair, but realized later that these traits that I found unlikeable were part of his character growth and story arc.

My difficulty relating to the character may have just been because I had certain expectations due to the other Gregory novels that I have read and loved. A big part of what drew me into her other books were the female protagonists and the struggles that women had to face in the time periods that her other books are set in.

This one begins in England in 1603, the year that Queen Elizabeth died and the Stuart era began. The main character is a gardener who works for a few different courtiers over the decades of his career, designing and planting great gardens.

He gets involved with traveling and bringing rare plants back to England, and being a collector of rarities becomes his trademark in the gardening world. This was interesting and a bit different, since I have never read a historical fiction novel that covered this ground before(I tend to get bored with the same old court intrigue and bitchy, rich people spending money and having affairs).

If you garden and know plants you will probably enjoy this book very much and if you don't, you may find yourself a bit bored with all of the plant talk, but it is still worth reading.

There is a sequel called Virgin Earth that I am interested in reading to see what happens next. It will follow the main character's son to Virginia and I think that I will enjoy that one more. I found the son a little easier to identify with and I empathized with him more.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on
Helpful Score: 3
Enjoyed this book so much have been reading way too late at night. Cannot put it down. I am that way with most of Gregorys books.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 141 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
I enjoyed this book enormously, but am ashamed to admit that I had completed both this book and its sequel before I realized that the main characters, John Tradescant the Elder and his son, (John the Younger)were true historical figures. They were the first botanists in England and England's most famous gardeners. A teriffic story of a man's unquestioning loyalty to his master and King. If you read this book, be sure to follow up with the sequel, Virgin Earth. Philippa Gregory never disappoints me.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 67 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
I normally love books by Philippa Gregory. This book I could not even finish. Skip this one and read another one of her books.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 44 more book reviews
This is Philippa Gregorys usual well written story of English royalty and the politics, intrigue, deception and corruption of 17th century England. King James is newly crowned the King of England and he has surrounded himself with loyal trusted advisors such as Cecil Roberts and the Duke of Buckingham. The story is told from the point of view of John Tradescant, the gardener for these men. Johns skill as a gardener catches the attention of the powerful men of England who want to create a showcase garden in their palaces to show off their wealth to the royal court.

Although this book has a lot of details of plants, I enjoyed all the descriptions and especially of the travels to procure plants rare to England. This is not simply a book about the gardens of England, but the character development of John and his son John show how the attitudes of the English common people are changing towards their royalty and their quest for freedom and the ability to possess their own private land. What is happening in America at this time is having an impact on the English populace and they are starting to get dissatisfied with the extravagance of the English royalty while the country is suffering from bad harvests and the plague. Although I enjoyed this book, this is not my favorite book by this author. There were some places where she went into too much of the same detail and the book dragged in a few places.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 25 more book reviews
In my opinion it was not her best work. My favorite of hers would be "The Other Boleyn Girl". However, the theme was very interesting. The book is based on the story of a head gardener for the king Charles I of England and previously to several other important historical figures such as the Duke of Buckingham and Sir Robert Cecil. He was a most respected gardener who was also a botanist and traveller and who introduced many species of plants, trees and flowers from all over the world to the famous English Gardens that we know and love. What impressed me was the fact that Mrs. Gregory based her novel on a figure of such humble importance and made the book so believable and interesting. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes the genre of historical fiction, gardening, English royal history or has read other Philippa Gregory books.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 366 more book reviews
Philippa Gregory, the great writer of historical fiction, places this one in 17th century England. Times book review said "this tale of forbidden love set against the turmoil of a country in chaos makes for both intelligent and satifying reading. This book, written in 1998 has a sequel, Virgin Earth
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 33 more book reviews
I enjoyed this book, it was a little slower than some of her other books but as a gardener it was fascinating
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 118 more book reviews
Not one of my Gregory favorites, this novel tells the tale of a lowly, loyal gardener and his service to two shockingly different lords. Perhaps because she does not have real life, larger than life kings to write about, the characters feel small and unreal. A decent, easy read, but not her best.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 9 more book reviews
If you love historical fiction, this one is a can't miss read!
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 72 more book reviews
fantasic book, can't wait to read the sequel
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 242 more book reviews
John Tradescant, the protagonist in this novel, was a great gardener in the post-Elizabethan era. The wonderful work that he did was achieved by obtaining samples of rare plants, unknown at that time, from around the world. He did not name any of them after himself, but his surname was given to a family of flowering plants from the New World: Transescantia, known to many people as spiderwort, a very pretty trailing vine with star shaped flowers. Some of his gardening achievements were unique for his time, such as enclosing gardens in hollow brick walls that were heated so that sub-tropical plants would bear fruit. The records of his trip to Russia are still extant. Since so little is available about his life, I recommend this book if you are at all interested in the history of gardening in England.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 5 more book reviews
Interesting read about a simple gardener who finds himself caught in court intrigue.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 422 more book reviews
As a Philippa Gregory fan since THE OTHER BOLEYN GIRL, I'm sad to say that EARTHLY JOYS was a big disappointment for me. The main character, John Tradescant, a renowned 17th-century gardener, simply wasn't interesting enough to carry an entire narrative.

As written, he was SO two dimensional with annoyingly pathetic self-esteem, deriving his worth and value solely from his service to better men than himself, his Lords and Masters.

Perhaps he could've been a supporting character in a book about someone else, but 500+ pages of this man's slightness toward his own home and family, a devoted wife and son, in favor of his deep homosexual passions for noblemen was just plain meh.

The horticulture was interesting at times, but that component also became mundane after a while, especially if you're not into gardening!

I'm still yawning.

So I give EARTHLY JOYS 2/5 stars and certainly won't bother with the sequel. No thanks.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 2 more book reviews
As always, Gregory wrote a great book!
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 130 more book reviews
MB read. Excellent info appropriate for the immigrant Nash's.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 224 more book reviews
Whether he is nurturing a single rare seedling into a blossom or planning acres of royal gardens, John Tradescant's fame & skill as a gardener are unsurpassed in England. Tradescant's talents soon come to the attention of Duke of Buckingham, the lover of King Charles I.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 267 more book reviews
A really fun read--I love historical fiction!
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 15 more book reviews
A historical encounter with the royal gardner to the Duke of Buckingham. John Tradescant has always been faithful to his masters and his craft but he gambles everything and follows Buckingham to court, to war and to the forbidden territories of love.
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 13 more book reviews
This book deals with subject matter that is not my cup of tea....
reviewed Earthly Joys (Earthly Joys, Bk 1) on + 24 more book reviews
Lots of hot gay sex.