Search - Too Good To Be True

Too Good To Be True
Too Good To Be True
Author: Kristan Higgins
When Grace Emerson's ex-fianc? starts dating her younger sister, extreme measures are called for. To keep everyone from obsessing about her love life, Grace announces that she's seeing someone. Someone wonderful. Someone handsome. Someone completely made up. Who is this Mr. Right? Someone…exactly unlike her renegade neighbor Callahan O'Shea...  more »
ISBN-13: 9780373773558
ISBN-10: 0373773552
Publication Date: 2/1/2009
Pages: 384
  • Currently 4.1/5 Stars.

4.1 stars, based on 187 ratings
Publisher: HQN Books
Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
Other Versions: Hardcover
Reviews: Member | Amazon | Write a Review

Top Member Book Reviews

reviewed Too Good To Be True on + 21 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
Kristan Higgins is an author I stumbled upon somehow. Her books were not the usual type I liked but with her heart warming writing style she had me hooked from "One of the Guys." I read this book in about four hours because I couldn't put it down. If you need a break from your normal historical/contemporary romances where someone mistakenly marries someone/someone thought their divorce was final but finds out they're still married, this book would be a nice change of refreshing straightforwardness.

Grace has been making up boyfriends since she was a little girl so when her sister feels guilty for stealing Grace's fiance she makes up another one. Like the title says, this man is "too good to be true," but her family jumps at the chance to meet him. Wyatt Dunn is perfect, a pediatric surgeon that rescues cats in his spare time, its hard to find anything not to love in this new fake boyfriend. Meanwhile the house next door gets a new inhabitant in the form of the sexy ex-con Callahan O'Shea. He's everything a girl can dream about (minus the minimum security prison time he served) and Grace soon starts to feel a huge attraction for him. Sadly she still has to perpetuate the lie of the fake boyfriend in front of her family and that means doing it in front of Callahan as well. How can she date Callahan the ex-con when her family will compare him to the fake standards of Wyatt Dunn? There's also some pretty funny antics with her parents and her gay best friend that I'm not going to get into but they were quite hilarious.

This book is probably not going to change your life, but it is a pleasant diversion from everyday activities. The reason why I like Kristan's books so much is that the heroine of the book is someone that I can relate to and oftentimes I have done some of the same stupid things that she's done. Grace is one of those people that you would want as a friend and Callahan is a man that is very crush-worthy. Add in Grace's crazy family and you have a recipe for another great book. The only reason why I gave it four stars is because the plot is very formulaic in all of her books, but a plot I really enjoy so I'll keep reading them until the last one.
reviewed Too Good To Be True on + 84 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
As with all K.H. books, this book was witty and enormously entertaining. The characters were very true to life and relatable. Reading this books was a very enjoyable way to spend an afternoon.
reviewed Too Good To Be True on
Helpful Score: 1
I have read several of Kiristan Higgins books and have enjoyed them all. This is her best.
reviewed Too Good To Be True on + 301 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Once again I have mixed emotions about this author's book. There's a lot that's good here, but sometimes one false note is all it takes to take away the shine. That false note comes when the heroine comes clean about the boyfriend she made up to stop her family from pitying her when her ex-fiance gets engaged to her sister and the hero's reaction is that she's a liar and he coldly walks away. Up until that moment, I though Callahan was a great leading man. I'd have even allowed him that judgmental moment (as out of character as it was) if it had only lasted through the fight, but when he held onto it, it was like the author had suddenly replaced the hero with someone completely different and I lost respect. For him. Or maybe for the author. In the end, it doesn't matter. I'm happy when an author manipulates me skillfully, but when the characters start acting out of character so the author can make a difficult plot point work--when I can see the strings on the marionette, as I could here--it's not a good time.

Guess I'm done with this author.
Read All 21 Book Reviews of "Too Good To Be True"

Please Log in to Rate these Book Reviews

reviewed Too Good To Be True on + 962 more book reviews
More chick-flicky romantic comedy than the more scandalous affairs Ive become used to when it comes to romance, Kristan Higgins writing will have you smiling, bouncing, and sighing over this straight-up romance with the best of intentions.

Grace is a smart and funny woman with a really awkward weaknesses when it comes to talking to and about guys that will make you both pity and empathize with her. Sometimes her stupidity when it comes to guys drove me crazy: you kind of just want to shake her and yell in her face, SNAP OUT OF IT, ALREADY!

But when Grace is not making a fool of herself regarding guys, shes the best, with an endearingly geeky love of Civil War reenactments (have you ever met a character who was into Civil War reenactments? I didnt think so) and appreciation for teaching history. This makes it totally possible for us to cheer for her happy ending, when she finally gets itand Callahan is no slacker in the ideal guy department, if yanno what I mean.

Complete with zany family members and laugh-out-loud dialogue, Kristan Higgins books will now be on my radar forevermore when Im looking for a sweet and funny romance. Highly recommended!
reviewed Too Good To Be True on + 3 more book reviews
easy read, entertaining
reviewed Too Good To Be True on + 47 more book reviews
Have you ever been dumped, only to find it's because he is in love with your sister? If so, then you will know what Grace is going through. If not, the author knows how to make you feel it. Now everyone looks at her like she is forever doomed, so what is a girl to do? Make up a boyfriend of course. But what's a girl to do when she looks out the window and sees her sexy new neighbor? Dump the boyfriend and try her luck? Grace can tell you though, things are always that easy.

Book Wiki

Original Publication Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Callahan O'Shea (Primary Character)
Important Events