Colorado high school students, Emilee and Christa Lawrence want only one thing in the new year. They both want their mother Sharon to find a man. It kills the Lawrence siblings that their mom is staying home on New Year's Eve because she has no one to date. The sisters decide to find their mother a man. They even tell their plan to a bemused Gabe Malone, whose company is renovating Sharon's home.
Not long into the New Year, Emilee and Christa begin to parade one male after another to their mother in hopes she will find Mr. Right. At first, Gabe finds the endless stream of men amusing, but as he begins to know Sharon, he desires to be the final person in the single man march.