Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of The Mermaid's Mirror

The Mermaid's Mirror
The Mermaid's Mirror
Author: L. K. Madigan
ISBN-13: 9780547194912
ISBN-10: 0547194919
Publication Date: 10/4/2010
Pages: 320
Reading Level: Young Adult
Rating:
  • Currently 4/5 Stars.
 2

4 stars, based on 2 ratings
Publisher: Houghton Mifflin Books for Children
Book Type: Hardcover
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

2 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

alterlisa avatar reviewed The Mermaid's Mirror on + 335 more book reviews
There's something drawing Lena to the water.
It's making Lena sleepwalk to the beach.
It's compelling her to surf even if it means putting herself in grave danger
and going against her father's wishes.
A woman emerges from the waves--a woman with a silvery tail.
She has a message.
She has a key
When Lena finds a brown leather sea chest and uses the key to unlock it, she has no choice but to look into the watery depths of her secret past through the mysterious mermaid's mirror . . .
Lena's life will never be the same.

This book started out pretty much the same way a lot of YA books do. Her parents dont understand her and she feels like a fish out of water, literally. Then she discovers that shes different from everyone else (big surprise) and sets out to discover what her heritage is really about. Though the first part of the book was a bit slow, once the Merpeople took over; the story became more of a fantasy read. Madigan did a credible job of building this world under the sea and I think it will greatly appeal to middle schoolers. I see mermaids taking over the YA paranormal world of vamps and weres. The use of the mirror added a different slant to the story but it could have been used more to help us understand this new world and the history behind it.
Lena was pretty much the typical teenager, whiny and constantly lying and hiding things from her parents. She does tend to face things head on and with a lot of courage, though. I saw that there was to be a sequel which I hope will flesh out parts of the story that were rather lacking. This light summer read will bring memories of sand and salt water with every flip of the page for the reader, both young and old alike.
reviewed The Mermaid's Mirror on + 3 more book reviews
I love this book, but it feels like a one-time book. I read it, loved it, then had that feeling where I knew I would never read it again and the poor thing would sit on my shelf, untouched, and gather dust. I loved the imagery and mental pictures, but the story kind of lost me. I love mermaids, so it was lovely to read a story about them, and I loved the mystery and the slight insanity. It was a very good book, I just don't think I'll read it again. The writing style was cool--it started out fast, then slowed down, then sped up at the end, kind of like a wave, although it took some getting used to.