Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Discussion Forums - Love & Romance Love & Romance

Topic: North and South by Elizabeth Gaskell

Club rule - Please, if you cannot be courteous and respectful, do not post in this forum.
  Unlock Forum posting with Annual Membership.
labgirl36 avatar
Standard Member medalFriend of PBS-Silver medal
Subject: North and South by Elizabeth Gaskell
Date Posted: 7/16/2008 9:11 AM ET
Member Since: 8/11/2007
Posts: 601
Back To Top

Another dumb question. Has anyone read this classic and if so what did you think ? I got the miniseries from the library after seeing it praised on another romance site. I loved the movie but haven't read the book. I think I'll have to buy the miniseries.

RomanceLVR avatar
Date Posted: 7/16/2008 10:08 AM ET
Member Since: 8/12/2006
Posts: 1,012
Back To Top

I have not read North and South, but have seen the movie which was pretty good.

I have and read Wives and Daughters and Cranford, both of which I enjoyed. 

I do plan to read North and South some day :-)

Sorry, not much help, but she is a good author and I suspect North and South is not primarily romance.

labgirl36 avatar
Standard Member medalFriend of PBS-Silver medal
Date Posted: 7/16/2008 10:14 AM ET
Member Since: 8/11/2007
Posts: 601
Back To Top

I think it's considered historical fiction with a little romance thrown in especially in the movie or maybe Richard Armitage made it seem more romantic. In any case, he seemed tortured to me.

riahekans avatar
Member of the Month medalFriend of PBS-Silver medal
Date Posted: 7/16/2008 2:58 PM ET
Member Since: 4/7/2008
Posts: 15,690
Back To Top

I read the book and loved it.

I saw the mini-series with Richard Armitage first and fell in love with Mr. Thornton. I couldn't stand Margaret so I thought if I read the book, I would understand her better. And I did! I wasn't as if I got to like her or anything, but in the book, her feelings for Mr. Thornton are more obvious - the byotch in the mini-series was too cold and you wondered why exactly she hooked up with him at the end. And of course, I fell in love with Mr. Thornton all over again.

The Armitage mini-series is pretty close to the book. They took some artistic liberties (with the end and the way the meet) but it added to the richness of the story.

I don't think the book is "Historical Fiction" as the book is set in Gaskell's lifetime (early industrial era.)  She was a contemporary of Dickens and she published the story in installments (in one of his publications, I believe.)  It's not romance, either, although that's part of the story.