Book Reviews of Oh, What a Thanksgiving

Oh, What a Thanksgiving
Oh What a Thanksgiving
Author: Steven Kroll
ISBN-13: 9780590406161
ISBN-10: 0590406167
Publication Date: 11/1989
Pages: 32
Reading Level: Ages 4-8
Rating:
  • Currently 4.5/5 Stars.
 2

4.5 stars, based on 2 ratings
Publisher: Scholastic Trade
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

2 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed Oh, What a Thanksgiving on + 31 more book reviews
Think it would be fun to be a pilgrim?
reviewed Oh, What a Thanksgiving on
ISBN 0590448749 - Reading my way through some of the Thanksgiving books on the shelves here has given me a new appreciation for what they can be, but few of them are. Oh, What a Thanksgiving! is one of those that has a little originality, which is a big plus.

David's teacher ignites David's imagination when he tells the class about the first Thanksgiving. As he goes through his day, David imagines himself in the days of the Pilgrims. He sees his house as a pilgrim cottage and imagines hunting for turkey while he and his father shop in the supermarket. David becomes convinced that Thanksgiving was better way back then, until he runs into his teacher on the holiday, who points out to him that some things don't change and people, now and then, are thankful for the same things: homes, friends, and family. With that in mind, his imagination keeps going, but David is able to celebrate Thanksgiving happily with his family.

Marked for ages 6 to 9, this is a book that relies heavily on the way that illustrations and text work together and Kroll and Schindler do a nice job there. As an adult, it strikes me as silly that David is bothered that his current Thanksgiving won't be "real" because it isn't like the "first" Thanksgiving - and the first Thanksgiving is the one that isn't real! Still, the book isn't non-fiction and the target audience isn't adults, but kids - and kids will enjoy getting to actually see David's imagination run wild.

For the politically correct crowd, the Indians are called Indians, not Native Americans. For the religious and non-religious, no reference is made to any god; whether you find that to be good or bad, at least you know going in! For me, this is not a great book, but it's a pretty good book with something that makes it stand out in a field of thin competition.

- AnnaLovesBooks