Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of The Scottish Duke (Duke Trilogy, Bk 1)

The Scottish Duke (Duke Trilogy, Bk 1)
The Scottish Duke - Duke Trilogy, Bk 1
Author: Karen Ranney
ISBN-13: 9780062466877
ISBN-10: 0062466879
Publication Date: 11/29/2016
Pages: 384
Rating:
  • Currently 3.9/5 Stars.
 19

3.9 stars, based on 19 ratings
Publisher: Avon
Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

4 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

chamber-maid avatar reviewed The Scottish Duke (Duke Trilogy, Bk 1) on
I really DID NOT LIKE the first 50 pages of this book! But, I always give a book 100 pages before I give up - and I'm SO GLAD I didn't stop reading it!

This ended up being one of the best "marriage of convenience" stories that I've read in a very long time. The H/h were well-written but the ancillary characters were as well.

4.5 stars
jjares avatar reviewed The Scottish Duke (Duke Trilogy, Bk 1) on + 3264 more book reviews
After Lorna Gordon's father (a scientist) died, Lorna became a maid at Blackhall Castle. Although she was raised as a gentleman's daughter, Lorna realized that she had to do something to support herself. She also planned to continue with her father's work. Lorna is very attracted to her employer, Alex Russell (Duke of Kinross). Alex has had a difficult life, although he was surrounded by opulence and wealth. Alex was married before, but his wife had died in childbirth after rubbing Alex's nose in her multiple infidelities.

Although the servants are well-treated, Alex is indifferent to every one. One night, Lorna decides to attend a masked, costume ball at the Duke of Kinross's home (where she is employed). She dresses like Marie Antoinette. Alex and Lorna have a wild tryst but they separate when he insults her. Months later, they meet again. Alex realizes that she wants nothing to do with him, while he thought she was after his money. Slowly, he comes to realize that Lorna is a resourceful woman with an independent spirit, and starts to admire her.

All the characters seemed well-defined. There is also a mystery or two. Both of the main characters grow in this book; Alex has more work to do than Lorna. There is so much action in this book that a reader will probably finish it quickly. It flows quite well.
scoutmomskf avatar reviewed The Scottish Duke (Duke Trilogy, Bk 1) on + 2543 more book reviews
Good book with an unusual plotline. Lorna is the daughter of a gentleman who has fallen on hard times since her father's death. She takes a position of a maid at Blackhall Castle where she becomes intrigued by the Duke. She takes advantage of a costumed ball to dress up and meet him, and maybe have a chance to dance with him. Alex is in a rotten mood the night of the ball. He has just suffered a professional disappointment and is well on the way to drowning his sorrows when he spots Lorna. There's something about her that immediately draws him to her.

Neither one expects the desire that hits them, and they are helpless to resist the passion that overtakes them. But Alex has been burned by passion before and his ability to trust women severely damaged. He accuses Lorna of using her innocence to trap him. She flees, but not before telling him exactly what she thinks of him. Alex is unable to forget her, and spends a fair amount of time looking for her, never noticing that she lives under his roof. However, their encounter has consequences, and when Lorna discovers she's pregnant, she leaves Blackhall, determined to raise her child on her own.

Lorna is very stubborn and independent. Her life after leaving Blackhall is not easy, especially as she is not married. I loved her friend and fellow maid, Nan, who worries about Lorna's safety. I loved how she took matters into her own hands and ratted out Lorna to Alex's mother. The scene between Alex and his mom was hilarious, as she takes him to task. He doesn't want to believe what he's told but eventually, goes to see Lorna. It doesn't go well for him, and I loved how Lorna stood up to him, his attitude, and his accusations. But she is also guilty of a bit too much pride and doesn't want to admit she needs help. That becomes especially obvious when she runs afoul of the more puritanical townspeople. Alex arrives just in time to save her from danger.

I loved the development of their relationship. Alex's fascination with her has not abated, and it has him rather freaked out. He moves her into a cottage on the estate grounds to take care of her. He can't stay away from her and finds himself spending more and more time with her. He's intrigued by the way her mind works, her independence, and the talent he sees in her artwork. He discovers that he likes spending time with her and wants to share so much of his life and thoughts with her. What disturbs him the most is that the emotions he had walled off since his late wife's betrayal and death are starting to resurface. Lorna also finds that her feelings for him are changing. Before she had been infatuated, but what she feels now is deeper and stronger. When Alex's mother convinces them both that they should marry for the sake of the child, they agree.

I got a bit frustrated with Alex here because as soon as the wedding was over (just in the nick of time), he runs away. He can't handle the torrent of emotions that he's experiencing and leaves to bury himself in his work. This leaves Lorna to deal with her new circumstances without his support. I loved that she had his mom and her maid thoroughly on her side. She spends the next several weeks settling in, and I loved the changing and maturing that she experienced. I completely enjoyed that Alex was miserable. He redeemed himself a little with his reaction to what his gossipy valet told him. The surprise arrival of his uncle was an additional motivator.

There are great changes once he arrives back at Blackhall. I loved seeing Alex become enchanted by his son. There are several really sweet moments between the two of them as Alex's emotions continue to reassert themselves. He and Lorna grow closer as he begins to accept the way she makes him feel, though he still refuses to put it into words. I also liked that Lorna lets him know that disappearing again isn't an option.

But there is someone at Blackhall who isn't happy about Lorna's place there. Someone destroys her supply of herbs and so on, and later tries to poison her. Alex is determined to discover who it is. There are several possibilities. Could it be Thomas, angry that he is no longer Alex's heir? Maybe Matthew, Alex's valet, who has made no secret of his disdain for the maid turned duchess? Or could it be Mary, sister of Alex's late wife, who was hoping to snag Alex for her own? Things get very intense when the baby disappears, and they must find him before it's too late. The final confrontation was the catalyst that opened Alex's eyes at last.

The secondary characters were all very well done. Thomas was an interesting character that kept me guessing as to his real intentions. I love to see him get a story of his own. I loved Alex's mom, Louise. She was a such a warm-hearted woman, and her immediate acceptance of Lorna was great. I also liked the way that she had of straightening Alex out. Mary was a straight up bitch of the first order. She was selfish, mean-spirited, and ultimately quite vicious. Definitely a character I loved to hate. Lorna's friend and fellow maid Nan was wonderful. She was a good balance to Lorna at the beginning, trying to keep Lorna out of trouble. She also proved herself to be a true friend when she overrode Lorna's wishes and informed the duchess of Lorna's pregnancy.
Jerseygirltoo avatar reviewed The Scottish Duke (Duke Trilogy, Bk 1) on + 452 more book reviews
Quite good marriage of convenience story-and the hero's mother was one of the best characters!