Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of Simon the Coldheart

Simon the Coldheart
Simon the Coldheart
Author: Georgette Heyer
ISBN-13: 9780449243459
ISBN-10: 0449243451
Publication Date: 1979
Pages: 287
Rating:
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
 11

3.5 stars, based on 11 ratings
Publisher: Fawcett
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

5 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

Jerseygirltoo avatar reviewed Simon the Coldheart on + 452 more book reviews
This book is written in a sort of antiquated faux medieval prose style. Quaint, but I didn't have any trouble getting used to it. It's really Simon's life story, beginning when he was a teenager, so it's more of an adventure than a romance. His eventual love interest does not show up until much later in the book, and as with many medievals, the sexual politics are a real throwback. Nevertheless, I was engrossed in his character and adventures, as portrayed by Heyer, and enjoyed it very much. Good historical details and some touches of humor too. That woman could really tell a story.
dizz avatar reviewed Simon the Coldheart on + 625 more book reviews
Interesting tale, told in a sort of high fantasy faux medieval style, about the rise of the talented bastard son of an English noble. Lots of chivalry, high flown language, honor, passionate declarations and adventure. It is, however, such a sanitized version of the era (no mud, no torture, hardly any mention of illness or brutality) that for me it is either a boy's/young adult novel or an outright fantasy. But after a while I got into it and enjoyed it for what it was. It's quite dated, though, so I wouldn't recommend it to everyone.
virgosun avatar reviewed Simon the Coldheart on + 886 more book reviews
I'd say this is more a saga about Simon's rise from lowly bastard to revered leader with a little romance thrown in to aid his transformation from cold heart soldier to smitten lover. Margot's pride butts heads with Simon's arrogance, keeping them at odds with each other almost until the very end, which may be more frustrating for romance seekers. However, it's a good pick for readers looking for a medieval adventure. Not bad for a story written almost a century ago. 4 stars.
reviewed Simon the Coldheart on + 14 more book reviews
Great historical setting...
a little slow - but overall worth the read.
Beautiful interpretation of Wordsworth's relationships...
StacyFreeElf avatar reviewed Simon the Coldheart on
This is the 1979 version.