It has all of the "classic" elements of the British murder mystery: the castle, an island, an oddly assorted company, a butler, an interesting wealthy man, assorted relatives, and a grisly murder. Cordelia must sort out everything in the end, and even though the ultiumate outcome is somewhat in doubt, there's rarely a dull moment throughout this book. You follow Ms. Gray's progress avidly, and try to keep up with what's going on around her to gather your own clues about the murder. I'll admit that I was shocked at the resolution of the mystery, and that's one of the reasons I enjoyed the book so much.
Actress Clarissa Lisle was famous for her ravishing beauty--and her unscrupulous manipulations. Now on the death-shrouded island of Courcy, her schemes win her a starring role in a nightmare in which she can trust no one--ont her deceived husband; her dangerouly insecure stepson; her ominously genial host; her dependent, desperate cousin; or her cruelly amusing ex-lover.
Soon detective Cordelia Gray will find that nothing is as it seems on Courcy--especially after the curtain goes down. Here she must delve into ancient secrets and guilt-stained pasts--and risk her life to stop a brilliantly cunning murdererr who has set the stage for death.
"This is a storybook killing: a close circle of suspects, isolated scene of crime conveniently cut off from the mainland, known terminus a quo and terminus ad quem," remarks one of the suspects in this book, and he has hit upon the strength of the plot. All the suspects have motives for both the poison pen letters and the murder: who was the culprit? Was there a separate culprit for the letters and the murder? Perhaps the letters were sent by more than one person? The armchair detective gets a lot of bang out of this mystery!
I read this right after finishing the first Cordelia Gray mystery. After the fuss James made in her Author's Note for "An Unsuitable Job for a Woman" about setting the mystery in the real town of Cambridge and not fabricating a cutesy "Oxbridge" setting, I was surprised that "Skull" is set in a completely fictional locale. Of course the island of Courcy is made-up, the little island with its castle and intricate history and geography is a custom setting for the mystery. But the island is reached from the nearby coastal town of Speymouth in Dorset, and James describes Cordelia's sunny walk from the train station to the wharf so vividly that I went straight to Google to find a photo of the statue of Queen Victoria there, only to find there is no such place as "Speymouth."
This book was published ten years after the first Cordelia Gray mystery and according to the dates mentioned in the book, it is set around 1981 when it was written, so about ten years have elapsed in Cordelia's life since the first book. It doesn't really feel like a decade has elapsed, though. Cordelia was 22 in the first book so she must be about 32 in this book, but the other characters treat her like a very young woman. In fact when Lady Ralston tells her stepson about the "girl" she's bringing to the island, she tells him how nice it will be for him to have "someone young on the island for you to practice talking to." It's hard to imagine a 17-year-old finding a 32-year-old "young." Maybe this just goes to show how superannuated all the other characters are (except the stepson of course!). Cordelia's life hasn't changed much, though, nor her perspectives and attitudes, as far as I could tell. It would be easy to imagine that this book was set a year or two after the first.
I give the book a mediocre rating primarily due to my lack of enthusiasm for Cordelia as a character. I don't understand sometimes why she says and does what she does. She spends her first evening on the island with her nose in Sherlock Holmes stories in the library when I think she should have been mingling with the other guests to try to get information about who might have sent the poison pen letters. Truly, I don't think Lady Ralston was getting her money's worth! Lady Ralston is another enigmatic personality, her peculiarities can't be explained other than by saying she is an actress so she has these little eccentricities. (Which are essential to the plot, by the way.)
The setting is a house party, but as PD James readers will know, a PD James house party will be quite different than the others -- much deeper delving into carefully crafted characters and a mystery cleverly sorted out by Cordelia Gray.
Second book in the Cordelia Grey mysteries. Cordelia is invited to the sunlit island of Courcey to protect the beautiful actress Clarissa Lisle. Very intricate and literate. I enjoyed this book very, very much.
Protecting a death-threatened actress, private detective Cordelia Gray finds that her own life is in grave danger. This is a masterly version of the clue-and-alibi game, combining the enclosed setting of the country-house murder with elements of the horror story, an overlay of lust and hairbreadth escapes.