Tami C. (ladyfire) reviewed I read this hoping for a good treasure hunt...... on 9/29/2008

Helpful Score: 4

...but I was sorely disappointed. The book bounces back and forth, sometimes rather disconcertingly, between modern day and about 200 years ago. Although some of the scenery described is beautiful and fans of New England autumns will enjoy that aspect, there isn't a lot else to recommend this rather cumbersome tale. The modern day thriller-type situations are highly improbable to the point of being ridiculous. The characters are neither engaging nor particularly likable. There is a romance brewing throughout that apparently we (the readers) are supposed to be rooting for, but I couldn't seem to find even a bit of interest in whether or not these two ever got together. I couldn't even figure out why they WOULD get together....I didn't like them much, and I couldn't see what they saw in each other.

As far as suspense goes, there really is none. Seriously. If you can get through the first two chapters, sit down and jot down on a bit of paper what you think happened to the constitution and how it all ends. Go ahead. Bet you're right! It's that predictable. This book honestly feels like the work of an author who sat down and said "Today I shall write a book that will be a major motion picture!" and then proceeded to cram as many car chases, helicopter stunts, explosions, etc. into it as possible, while still trying to be "historical", and then for some odd reason (maybe he lost a bet?) had to weave in a love story that just didn't really fit.

If you have nothing better to do on a rainy day, this book will fill a few hours of your time. If you are looking for a truly engaging page-turner that will give you something to talk about with your friends for the next few weeks, this is probably not the book for you.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details