Yvonne L. reviewed on 12/7/2011 + 929 more book reviews

Not as good as the first one but still a decent read. It had a slow start so it was harder for me to get involved. When Willow actually meets Rick, she had a really annoying persona. She would turn everything they said into a sexual innuendo. It wasnt clever, just juvenile. It stopped after they get together so the last half of the book was less annoying.

I think the side characters were what made this book worthwhile for me. I loved the scene with Ricks grandmother even though she was too much like the Prophecy in the Matrix. Morgan and Weinberg were great characters and I wished more time was spent on them.

Obviously Perry is a Star Wars fan but I thought the Luke, Im your father scenario was taking it a little too far. My favorite parts were when all the guardians get together but there werent enough of those scenes.

Overall, it was an okay book. I wouldnt want to spend a credit on it but I will continue to read the series. Most likely there will be one more book in the series (the guardian of water and the chosen one). You have to like cheesy to enjoy these books.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details