Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Review of First Degree (Andy Carpenter, Bk 2)

First Degree (Andy Carpenter, Bk 2)
jjares avatar reviewed on + 3290 more book reviews


Finding the headless and charred body of Alex Dorsey is the opening salvo of this great story. I liked it even better than the first Andy Carpenter story, OPEN AND SHUT (see below).

Alex Dorsey was a cop with doubtful ethics; Andys love interest, Laurie Collins, blew the whistle on his dishonest dealings while she was a police officer. The only thing that changed was that Laurie left law enforcement and became a private investigator.

When the police start looking for the Alexs killer, Laurie looks like the perfect choice. Theres lots of circumstantial evidence against her. The pacing is fantastic; Andy and Kevin (Andys lawyer associate) rush to punch holes in the meticulously-orchestrated frame up of Laurie. I dont know how Rosenfelt does it; although tension mounts, bodies keep falling the jokes keep coming.

This was a well-crafted, quick read. This seemed to be the perfect mystery until the last few pages; they just seemed unnecessary.

Andy Carpenter
1. Open and Shut (2002)
2. First Degree (2003)