Rachelle K. (storyeyes) reviewed on
The purpose of this graphic novel seems to be blending science fiction and family in order to get across the message that teenagers really should listen to their parents more. I don't disagree with the message, I just think the delivery was awkward and a little forced.
The book starts with a frame story--an alien race is under attack. Flash forward to a human family going on a boat trip. The teenager doesn't listen, the little girl can't get anyone to help her find her pet snake, the dad is scatterbrained trying to get his family on the road, and the mom is checking to make sure the house doesn't fall apart while they're gone. It centers on the teenage boy, Reese, who is probably the most developed character, but he still feels flat by the end of the graphic novel.
I think the problem is that TenNapel wanted to do too much with this novel and ended up failing to develop either the frame story or the main story adequately. The story switches back and forth between the two, spending much more time with the family, who are stranded on a hostile island fighting for their lives. The ending is too perfect, and there are too many questions left unanswered, but it is a fun adventure story.
The book starts with a frame story--an alien race is under attack. Flash forward to a human family going on a boat trip. The teenager doesn't listen, the little girl can't get anyone to help her find her pet snake, the dad is scatterbrained trying to get his family on the road, and the mom is checking to make sure the house doesn't fall apart while they're gone. It centers on the teenage boy, Reese, who is probably the most developed character, but he still feels flat by the end of the graphic novel.
I think the problem is that TenNapel wanted to do too much with this novel and ended up failing to develop either the frame story or the main story adequately. The story switches back and forth between the two, spending much more time with the family, who are stranded on a hostile island fighting for their lives. The ending is too perfect, and there are too many questions left unanswered, but it is a fun adventure story.
