Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of Coming Home

Coming Home
Coming Home
Author: Rosamunde Pilcher
ISBN-13: 9780340646854
ISBN-10: 0340646853
Publication Date: 4/4/1996
Rating:
  • Currently 4.5/5 Stars.
 5

4.5 stars, based on 5 ratings
Publisher: Hodder Stoughton
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

36 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

Leigh avatar reviewed Coming Home on + 378 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 11
One of the most powerful, memorable books Pilcher has ever written. You watch young Judith grow up from an awkward girl to a determined, strong woman. You see her truly come into her own, all through the back-drop of WWII, and all while her entire family is missing for years at a time. You appreciate the struggles Judith goes through to maintain a semblance of normalcy in life and you appreciate more the human kindness shown to her by the Carey-Lewises, whom you grown to love almost as much as she does. Warning: You will probably experience some separation anxiety when this book ends. I know I did.
reviewed Coming Home on + 12 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 4
As with The Shell Seekers, I could not put this book down. Rosamunde Pilcher is one of my most favorite authors and her books are so beautifully written, you just get lost in the story. If you are going to start with any of her books, this one I highly recommend!
reviewed Coming Home on + 15 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 3
This was my first Pilcher book and I didn't know what to expect. From the first moment, I could not put it down! Pilcher has an incredible writing style that pulls you in and creates multi-layered characters. A wonderful author and a great read! You won't be disappointed!
reviewed Coming Home on + 13 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
A story of a girl left in England at a boarding school and finding her family and her place after the years go by.
reviewed Coming Home on + 179 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Set in the days preceeding, during, and after World War II in Cornwall, London, and other other spots, the reader is introduced to Judith Dunbar at age 14. She is left at a girls' school in England while her mother and younger sister Jess go to join Judith's father in Singapore. The separation stretches on for years, and Judith grows through her teen years with the help of new-found friends, the affluent Carey-Lewises, but mostly survives due to her own indomitable spirit.
reviewed Coming Home on + 153 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
This is about a young girl named Judith Dunbar and the people around her. It's a sweet story about life at the very beginning of WWII (Right before it started). I liked the characters and the general story idea, but I had trouble really getting into it. I'm not really a big fan of historical fiction. You might enjoy reading about Judith's life as she's separated from her family and must live life with a wide range of different characters.
reviewed Coming Home on + 180 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
This is Rosamunde Pilcher's most interesting books with characters and relationships that are totally involving. A great English writer.
reviewed Coming Home on + 2 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
A favorite! Another great story by Pilcher!
aafolk avatar reviewed Coming Home on
Helpful Score: 1
I have read everything that I could ever get my hands on by Ms. Pilcher, and this book is my favorite. I love her locations. I love that her characters are so REAL. They reflect all of the highs and lows that life brings to bear. I especially enjoy books set in England between the two World Wars, so the time frame was perfect to me. This is one that I re-read every couple of years, and it is always like a reunion with a wonderful, dear friend.
reviewed Coming Home on + 8 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Like the Shell Seekers, this one is set in beautiful Cornwall. One of her best books
reviewed Coming Home on + 30 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
A charming look back in time. You see that most likely things weren't as simple then as they seem today.
reviewed Coming Home on
This is my all time favorite! Great story of a young girl growing up in England from pre-WWII England to post-WWII.
reviewed Coming Home on + 9 more book reviews
A story of an extraordinary young woman, Judith Dunbar. Teeming with marvelous, memorable characters, Coming Home is a book to be savored, reread and cherished.
LeahG avatar reviewed Coming Home on + 320 more book reviews
I loved this book and didnt want it to end and thought it was as good or maybe even better than The Shell Seekers.
tripledip3 avatar reviewed Coming Home on + 11 more book reviews
I wanted so badly to love this book. I adore historical novels, and novels set in England, and have enjoyed a couple of Ms. Pilcher's books I have read. But I just couldn't get into it. I would read a few pages and put it down, go for a walk at lunch instead of reading, surf the Net at home instead of reading, etc. It just moved far too slow for me, just dragged along. Plus I thought most of the characters were unbearably self-absorbed, shallow, and silly. I usually read 2-3 books a week, and after a week adn a half I was still only about 90 pages into this one, so I just gave up.
reviewed Coming Home on + 32 more book reviews
I loved this story. It transported em to a different time and place.
knittymama avatar reviewed Coming Home on + 424 more book reviews
25 cassettes long, but so worth it. This was a beautifully written story that never got bogged down for such a long story. Loved it! Donada Peters reads this audio book so well. She is my favorite audio book voice.
reviewed Coming Home on + 50 more book reviews
I loved this book and I love Rosamunde Pilcher. Always a good story with beautiful writing. Even though I know what will likely happen next, she paints such a lovely world (even though this novel takes place during WW 2) that it doesn't matter and I look forward to the time I can sit down and read. It makes me want to get on the next plane to Cornwall.
reviewed Coming Home on + 285 more book reviews
Teaming with marvelous, memorable cnaracters in a novel that is a true masterpiece, this is a book to be savored, reread, and cherished forever.
TakingTime avatar reviewed Coming Home on + 1072 more book reviews
This 977 page novel, set just prior to WW II, covering a number of nations, will bring one womans life from lonely childhood into the couragous depths of the war, unraveling her story...both good and bad
reviewed Coming Home on + 201 more book reviews
Set in England (actually some of it takes place in South Africa) from a little while before World War II until just after it. The main character is a girl in an English boarding school while her parents live in Singapore.

Quite a book! It brings in so many people and conditions and situations and global and national and social changes - and yet it manages to be very readable - and even take time for descriptions of places, the weather and what people were wearing.

I'm keeping my copy to reread someday.
reviewed Coming Home on + 174 more book reviews
Well written, interesting and a pleasure to read. This is one of several of her books that I've read and enjoyed them all.
reviewed Coming Home on + 144 more book reviews
This book is written by the author of The Shell Seekers and September. Excellent reads!
rapunzel avatar reviewed Coming Home on + 30 more book reviews
A wonderful story for the fan of historical fiction.
reviewed Coming Home on + 2 more book reviews
5 Stars!! I love Rosamunde Pilcher
reviewed Coming Home on + 22 more book reviews
Would have gotten 5 stars but it was 970 pages. Very descriptive but not boring. Life struggles and war times in the 1930's and 1940's so much different than today.
reviewed Coming Home on + 6 more book reviews
Absolutely wonderful book......Pilcher at her best! I could hardly put it down.....
reviewed Coming Home on + 91 more book reviews
Against the backdrop of an elegant Cornwall mansion before WWII and a vast continent spanning canvas during the turbulent war years, this imvolving story tells of an extra-ordinary young woman's coming of age, coming to grips with love and sadness, and in every sense of the term, coming home.

In 1935 Judith Dunbar is left behind at a British boarding school when her mother and babysister go off to join her father in Singapore. At Saint Ursula's, her friendship with Loveday Carey-Lweis sweeps her into the privileged, madcap world of the aristocracy, teaching her about values, friendship and wealth.
reviewed Coming Home on + 16 more book reviews
In 1935 Judith Dunbar is left behind at a British boarding school when her mother and baby sister go off to join her father in Singapore.Judith's friendship with Loveday Carey-Lewis sweeps her into the privileged, madcap world of the British aristocracy, teaching her about values, friendship, and wealth.
reviewed Coming Home on + 5 more book reviews
I have enjoyed all of Rosamund Pilcher's books especially Shell Seekers
boomerbooklover avatar reviewed Coming Home on + 431 more book reviews
Not sure why I got this book, but have read that R. Pilcher was a popular romance writer. This book is, in my opinion, more a regular novel about a family. While there are various romances of various characters, they are not the entire focus of the book. The older daughter is left in England to finish her education at a private girls' school while her mother and sister go East to live with her father. The main character is unofficially 'adopted' by the family of one of her classmates. Timeframe is from late 1930's until just after WWII. Although long, I enjoyed the story, and it ended well.
reviewed Coming Home on + 10 more book reviews
in 1935 Judith is left behind in Britian and must come of age during the highs and lows or war torn London
reviewed Coming Home on + 164 more book reviews
Against the backdrop of an elegant Cornwall mansion before World War II and a vast continent-spanning canvas during the turbulent war years, this involving story tells of an extraordinary young woman's coming of age, coming to grips with love and sadness, and in every sense of the term, coming home... IN 1935 Judith Dunbar is left behind at a British boarding school when her mother and baby sister go off to join her father in Singapore. At Saint Ursula's, her friendship with Loveday Carey-Lewis sweeps her into a privileged, madcap world of the British aristocracy, teaching her about values, friendship, and wealth. But it will be the drama of war, as it wrenches Judith from those she cares about most, that will teach her about courage...and about love.
CAJUN avatar reviewed Coming Home on + 339 more book reviews
MS . PILCHER HAS HER OWN SPECIAL WAY TO WRITE. LOVE ALL OF HER BOOKS
reviewed Coming Home on + 11 more book reviews
hardback
reviewed Coming Home on + 911 more book reviews
From an elegant British boarding school in the 1930s to a continent ravaged by World War II, Judith Dunbar comes of age and learns about love, courage, and loss.