Skip to main content
PBS logo

Book Reviews of The Lady Is Tempted

The Lady Is Tempted
The Lady Is Tempted
Author: Cathy Maxwell
ISBN-13: 9780380818334
ISBN-10: 0380818337
Publication Date: 7/1/2002
Pages: 384
  • Currently 3.6/5 Stars.

3.6 stars, based on 94 ratings
Publisher: Avon
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

12 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

susyclemens avatar reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 158 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 3
Plot: the widowed country mouse (and sexually supressed) Deborah Percival goes to visit her sister in London - on the way, thanks to a rainstorm, she meets Anthony, an Earl with long-standing emotional issues concerning his father's suicide and mother's abandonment of him. It's mad, passionate lust at first sight (and it really is from first sight, they're in bed together within three hours of meeting).

I thought this book was a piece of fluff. I guess you could call it a beach read. Whether it's a good beach read, I don't think so. The love story was, frankly, blah, and predictable. Mean characters become nice; selfish characters become giving & protective, and Anthony's mother tells him she never meant to hurt him. Very sappy-style plot and characterization and way too historically lightweight for my tastes, too -it's one of those books where characters act the way they want, and all is forgiven & forgotten by the end, without regard for the real social behavior of the era. I did like that Anthony was NOT presented as a rake or a bounder, and his relationship with his old nurse - but that's the only original thing about this Regency-era romance.
TruckerBarbie65 avatar reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 52 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 3
This book was fantastic. The storyline was great. I loved the characters. Very romantic, well written book.
Sabradoodles avatar reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 4 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
Good Book but not one of her best.
reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 929 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
I'm relatively new to Maxwell and have liked her other stuff but I thought this one was weak. It wasn't horrible just not as good as expected.

I don't know anything historically about the Regency period which might be the reason I had a hard time liking Deb and Tony. I preferred Maxwell's outspoken, flaunting society type of characters rather than repressed martyrs like Deb. Tony was just a jerk. He wanted everything but would only sacrifice his money for it. He had loads of it so who cares? I dont see why Deb would fall for him other than he was good in bed. Outside of taking care of his childhood governess, Tony really didnt have any redeeming qualities: he cheats on his fiancée, he wants to buy Deb like a whore, he thinks his mother is a whore, he plans to just impregnate his wife he doesnt care for and then skip town with Deb but at least everyone will get paid. Not the best guy around.

It also bothered me that the love scene in the coach has been used in another book of hers. I think it was actually word for word. I have something against authors recycling their work.

So overall I found it a disappointment. It was frustrating because reading about myrtyrs can be that way and it lacked the humor I come to like in her books.
reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 620 more book reviews
I'm always excited to find an excellent author whose books I've never read. This book is the first I've read by Cathy Maxwell, and I loved it!
Jenmonaco avatar reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 74 more book reviews
very good
reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 373 more book reviews
Historical romance.
reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 475 more book reviews
Sometimes the opportunity to misbehave is very tempting indeed, even for the most well-bred young lady.

Marry the local vicar -- a stodgy man with six impossible children -- never! Deborah Percival is determined to discover passion in a man's arms, not duty in a dull marriage. And when she becomes stranded at a countryside inn, tantalizing Anthony Aldercy, the Earl of Burnell, offers her the chance to fulfill her dreams. Deborah knows she should say no -- but how can she resist?

The Lady is tempted ...

The earl is determined to repair his roguish reputation -- and a marriage to a demure highborn lady of the ItonI will do this -- but he cannot deny Deborah's charms. Her lush curves tease his senses, while her delicious honesty touches his heart. But when she disappears, he's desperate, so he searches all of London to find her, refusing to rest until he brings her into his life -- and his arms -- again.

Perhaps Deborah is not the only one being tempted ...
reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 48 more book reviews
I really enjoyed this book. It's a fun read.
reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 10 more book reviews
Wonderful story set in 19th century England with period details, surprise surprise romance.
reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 3 more book reviews
A great story that tears at your heart and makes you want to keep reading for the outcome.
sugarsmom avatar reviewed The Lady Is Tempted on + 167 more book reviews
Society widely assumes that a proper young lady would no be tempted by an improper proposal - even from a handsome gentleman. Often society is wrong.