As a writer
Chloe Spooner from
The Bookbag praised Burgess'
Where Teddy Bears Come From (illustrated by Russell Ayto) writing, "The author Mark Burgess has created a wonderful world for children here in this book, and the extra dash of Christmas magic just makes an already lovely story all the more charming."
As an illustrator
Burgess shared a 2002
Blue Hen Book Award in the Picture Book Winner category for his and Allan Curless' illustrations in
Dogs' Night.
Burgess' illustration of
Return to the Hundred Acre Wood in particular received good reviews in
The Sunday Times as well as in
Fantasy Book Review and
Kidsreads.com. In
The Times, Ann Thwaite wrote, "With the new book, Burgess seems indispensable." Jana Siciliano of
Kidsreads.com, wrote:
"...illustrator Mark Burgess has studied the pen-and-ink-and-watercolor elegance of Ernest H. Shepard's original illustrations and created a beautiful book filled with iconic images rendered in such exacting fashion that one, for a moment, questions whether or not they are lost Shepard masterpieces (a two-page spread with all the characters playing cricket towards the end is worthy of framing). It’s one thing for someone to copy the language of a simple and elegant story, but it is something else entirely to do the same for famous illustrative accompaniment."
However, Susan Perren, children's book columnist of
The Globe and Mail, had reservations on the drawings found in
Return to the Hundred Acre Wood. Perren wrote, "This bad-tempered donkey might say, too, that Mark Burgess, as good an illustrator as he might be, is no Ernest Shepherd, and anyway, where are all those lovely line drawings we enjoyed so much in the original?"