Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of The Mistress of Tall Acre

The Mistress of Tall Acre
The Mistress of Tall Acre
Author: Laura Frantz
ISBN-13: 9780800720445
ISBN-10: 080072044X
Publication Date: 9/8/2015
Pages: 400
Rating:
  • Currently 4.4/5 Stars.
 12

4.4 stars, based on 12 ratings
Publisher: Revell
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

3 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

Moonpie avatar reviewed The Mistress of Tall Acre on + 1170 more book reviews
This is a "stay up all night, can't put it down, oh no it's 3 a.m.," novel! With the help of Ms. Frantz, I stepped back into the time after the American Revolution. As with the end of any war, there is confusion, upheaval, missing loved ones and division. Political allegiances were not as simple today with simply a cutting remark on Facebook. Those who supported the Tories and their extended families were viewed as traitors and endanger for the lives and properties.
Such was the position of Sophie. Her Tory father had fled to Scotland and she awaited news on whether her soldier brother was dead or alive. Times were hard and worked hard at barely surviving in her family home, Three Chimneys.
Adjoining her land was the wealthy estate of Tall Acre. Home to the highly acclaimed war hero and widower, Seamus Ogilvy. His child Lily Cate, wanders onto her land. Hungry for a mother's love the little girl becomes obsessively attached to Sophie and Sophie to her. Riddled with guilt over his wife's death while he was at war, Seamus finds his beautiful neighbor a welcome part of their lives. Here the seeds are planted for the beginning of a beautiful but complicated love story.
The author's skillful and descriptive writing of life during this time, gave me more than an historical view. I believe I could actually draw the pictures in my mind that she painted with words! The story is more than that, much more! Unexpected surprises and turns are so shocking that you might even audibly gasp! All this combined makes for a story you will not forget.
I received this book free from Revell Publishing. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I stated are my own.

.
biblegirl06 avatar reviewed The Mistress of Tall Acre on + 92 more book reviews
The author states in her notes ..."this was fun to write because of my own family heritage in Virginia, but mostly because of my continued awe, and appreciation of those first American Patriots. From the comforts of our twenty-first century homes and a world of instant everything, we often forget how long the revolutionary war was and how very turbulent and passionate that time period was. In the span of a novel I've attempted to portray a tiny slice of that era through the tenants of Tall Acre...through their sacrifices, courage, and vision they leave us an enduring, historically rich legacy."

This author creates believable characters I instantly cared about. I appreciated the rich historical detail without bogging the reader down. She also creates villains I loathed and there were some twists I didn't see coming. The treachery that Sophie and Seamus endured was deep, my heart ached for them. (I know they aren't real but it felt real!) I also felt like I was in the parlor with Sophie and General Seamus's younger daughter Lily Cate (who I adored) as the prepared to take tea.

Sophie's friend jokes with her about the tea party they have planned, "You wouldn't by any chance, have designs on the general by way of his little daughter?"

"Glynnis! You make the situation sound so conniving..."The truth is I'm lonely. I've always loved children. We've had no merriment at Three Chimney's for ages, even if it's a humble tea party." In the parlor

Lily and Sophie pray before their tea party. Sophie gives Lily one of her dolls she stored in the attic. A Pandora Doll. Lily Cate treasures the gift. I grew to admire Sophie. She is brave and has a strength to hang out at the manor waiting on her brother to return from war. She is determined to do the right thing as she is having to deal with running a household with little money and few servants. She has learned to lean on the Lord in hard times. She trusts the Lord to provide a way when there seems to be no way to survive.


Seamus is a General at the end of the war in 1783 who has suffered unimaginable horrors of war. The battle weary soldier would like to pick up his life where he left it and raise his lovely daughter. He's a widow who finds himself still in a battle on a whole new plain. It's unimaginable what he goes through.

Sophie Menzies wants to help General Seamus Ogilvy navigate fatherhood because she's developed a bond with his daughter. He needs help but so does she. Can they work together? Can she enter a marriage of convenience? Could he do the same?

I was captured by this story and their situations. I loved how this author Interwoven in the story historical facts, suspense, drama and mystery and their journey in faith. Seamus and Sophie walk a hard road which causes them to question all that they believe and stand for trust God's plan for their lives? Embark on their journey as a family? What was the right thing?

I liked getting glimpses of General Seamus interacting with General George Washington. I had read that this author is going to start having historical figures have dialogue in her novels. I enjoyed the peek at General Washington.

This is a sweet and tender love story with a few twists and turns; with a few heart-wrenching parts I was surprised by. This is a story you won't soon forget. I highly recommend this as a great escape and one that would be GREAT for book club. This story is rich with so much to talk about.

Disclosure of Material Connection: #AD Sponsor Revell
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255 "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising"


Nora St Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins! www.bookfun.org
The Book Club Network blog www.psalm516.blogspot.com
Book Fun Magazine www.bookfunmagazine.com
maydayzee avatar reviewed The Mistress of Tall Acre on + 749 more book reviews
The Mistress of Tall Acre is an amazing book. Wow! I love this story. The main characters are wonderful and full of life. The setting draws in the reader with its authenticity. The plotline is complex and full of twists, turns and tension. This novel is exactly what a historical fiction and romance should be. I highly recommend you move it to the top of your To-Be-Read pile.