Book Reviews of The Next Best Thing

The Next Best Thing
The Next Best Thing
Author: Kristan Higgins
ISBN-13: 9780373774388
ISBN-10: 0373774389
Publication Date: 2/1/2010
Pages: 384
  • Currently 4/5 Stars.

4 stars, based on 177 ratings
Publisher: HQN
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

16 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 265 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 5
I liked this book, but I didn't love it as much as some of her others (Just One of the Guys, for example...) I thought it was a bit slow to start- I kept putting it down for the first half of the book. The whole story probably could have been 75-100 pages shorter, and I might have liked it more. I felt it got bogged down a bit because the author kept harping on about how sad the main character was (having been widowed 5 years earlier), and I found myself saying, "I GET it, now let's move on!" The book ends with the trademark Higgins "warm & fuzzy" HEA though, so I was able to forgive some of it's overall flaws... I give it a 3 out of 5 stars.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 24 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 3
What the summary doesnt tell you is that Ethan is her deceased husbands brother. That is a line that I would not cross and I found it hard to accept Lucy and Ethan as a couple. I also didnt feel any chemistry between the two. It was very upsetting to see the way Lucys family treated her and the way Ethans family treated him a family supports you and loves you no matter what! I felt very upset and angry throughout the whole book and I got very sick of how much Lucy obsessed over her late husband. My least favorite Kristan Higgins book.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 97 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 3
Another winner by Kristin Higgins! I just love her books and usually stay up all night to finish them. It was no different with The Next Best Thing. I LOVED every character in this book, even Doral Anne. They all made for a crazy, zanie, dysfunctional good time. Lucy could be a little irritating at times with her complete and utter blindness when it came to her relationship with Ethan but I forgave her in the end and that seems to be the normal personality for Kristin's female leads and I've come to love every one of them, faults and all.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 19 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 3
What a sweet, funny, romantic story full of emotion, family, sadness and laughter. The first I've read from this author, will definitely seek out more. Great characterizations, laugh-out-loud dialogue, pointed emotional moments. You will laugh - and cry. At least I did. Ethan is an amazing heart-stealing hero, and while Lucy is a little annoying at times, anyone who's loved - or loved and lost - will understand her many insecurities. Could not put this down.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 301 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
At400 pages, this book is 100 pages too long. There are some fun things in this book but the heroine wallowed too much in the grief of being widowed. She was so blind to the hero's love that she was cruel to him. And selfish? Oh, man. Even at the end where she finally realized she wanted him, she had to tell him on her timetable. The hero was either a saint or a doormat, depending on how you want to see him. She walked all over him enough for me to vote for the later. What gripes me the most is that the author clearly knew this because a couple of secondary characters come right out and say it as when Parker tells the heroine that she's (the heroine likes hurting the hero and has been hurting him for years. Talk about dysfunctional, codependent relationships.

I just don't think I want to read any more from this author.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 46 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
I love all of Kristan Higgins's books, but this one is my least favorite. The main character, Lucy was unlikeable, selfish, & cried about every other page. However I loved the other characters & setting in this book. The story seemed to drag on & was pretty predictable, but still enjoyable. That being said, I'd recommend any of Kristan Higgins books & already looking forward to the next one myself.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 3 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
This was the first book I have read from Kristan Higgins and it won't be the last. I loved this book. Lucy was widowed only 8 months after she married Jimmie. Lucy and her Mother and Aunts who also were widowed, thought that there was a curse if one of the women married again that their husband would die. So, Lucy thought the best thing to do was just find someone that she wouldn't ever fall in love with. That might have worked if Ethan (Jimmie's younger brother) wasn't in the picture. Lucy and Ethan are best friends and when Lucy decides she is ready to date again. She tells Ethan that their "friends with benefits has to stop". I could not put this book down. This is definitely one for the keeper shelf.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 105 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
I read one of her books not long ago, it was okay. Thought I'd give her another try so glad that I did. This was a fabulous book. Good story line and fun characters. A real quick good read. I read it it one day, to me that makes it a great book when you can't put it down.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 6 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
A romantic comedy - babies, laughter and food - a little sex too - what more can a woman ask for? Will appeal to women in their 20-30's. Young widow is ready to "move on" after 3 yrs in mourning. Revolves around a Hungarian bakery. The main character gets the reader frustrated, like you want to shake her sometimes, but the "Black Widow" aunts are a hoot!
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 123 more book reviews
I also had an issue with the H being the brother. I found myself skipping parts of the book because of the "poor me" angst of the h. The writing was excellent (as always) with great dialogue and the tie-up finish was terrific but over-all I'd have been happier with a different relationship between the H&h.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 177 more book reviews
Great book! easy read and great story went from laughing to crying back to laughing!
reviewed The Next Best Thing on
I read this right after I read Catch of the Day. What a difference. While Catch of the Day has its faults, it's a very breezy, fun book that I finished in two days. The Next Best Thing is nothing like that. It's mired in its angst. The heroine is a basket case. The heroine, a widow for over five years, can't get over her husband's death. You'd think this was written a year after his death, not nearly six years out.

The story needed tighter editing. It could have been shortened by about 50 pages or so. There were also so many supporting characters to keep track of. The character development is flat. Not one of my favorite Kristan Higgins stories.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 52 more book reviews
I don't know that I'd ever read this author before but I will be reading her again. This book was great! At one point I actually said Oh my God...outloud! I had a few tears and overall enjoyed the ups and downs of the characters. I would recommend!
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 97 more book reviews
I love this author! Her stories are so sweet, but realistic, funny, happy & sad. And not full of a lot of sex (although I do like hot, sizzling stories, it's refreshing to read some that are not full of that, but still tell a good story that warms your heart). I actually read "Somebody to Love" before this one and loved that as well. The Next Best Thing should be read first as Somebody to Love is a sequel of sorts. I wish more of her books followed some of these same characters. I don't want the stories to end. 5 stars!
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 32 more book reviews
This is my favorite Kristan Higgins book! I have probably read it 5 times.
reviewed The Next Best Thing on + 21 more book reviews
Excellent Read