Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of A Plain & Fancy Christmas: A Novel

A Plain & Fancy Christmas: A Novel
A Plain Fancy Christmas A Novel
Author: Cynthia Keller
ISBN-13: 9780345528759
ISBN-10: 0345528751
Publication Date: 10/25/2011
Pages: 336
Rating:
  • Currently 4.1/5 Stars.
 21

4.1 stars, based on 21 ratings
Publisher: Ballantine Books
Book Type: Hardcover
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

3 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

DebbieinMaine avatar reviewed A Plain & Fancy Christmas: A Novel on + 112 more book reviews
Enjoyed this book very much. It moved along, not too fast or slow. A good read at any time of year as the "Christmas" part only takes place in the last chapter. The story begins earlier in the year and isn't focused on Christmas.
reviewed A Plain & Fancy Christmas: A Novel on + 3559 more book reviews
Beautiful Amish book about 2 babies one Amish and one English born in the same hospital get switched at birth. The girls 30 years later agree to visit their natural parents. The Amish daughter is afraid the her parents will want the switch to be permanent and she would be lost in the english world. Both daughters keep ties with with their birth parents and the parents who raised them. Both families become close even though they are much different and both daughters have a huge learning about them selves that take place. An original and well thought out book.

A beautiful book and a heartwarming story.
glarnerlad avatar reviewed A Plain & Fancy Christmas: A Novel on + 13 more book reviews
My assessment may be limited since this is the first novel about the Amish that I've read. But I thoroughly enjoyed it. The Amish of Pennsylvania were well researched by the author. And it was not another typical romance set in an exotic or historic locale. Romance was included but not until late in the book, and it was rather casual. And the Christmas part also was not addressed until the very end, which makes the title somewhat misleading.

To be sure, the book was published by Ballantine, and not Thomas Nelson or Bethany House or other Christian publisher. Therefore, the emphasis was not so much on divine faith as it was on Amish traditions. I personally didn't know such novels existed, published as it was by a secular publisher.

It's difficult to write about the plot in the interest of not revealing too much for the potential reader. However, the situation explored is no doubt very unusual. It is not a commonplace story at all, not in its plot, not in its Christmas theme and not in its Amish setting. It does deal with interaction between the Amish and the English.

The language I found to be faultless, the novel being free of clichés and such. This is a novel that will surely be enjoyed by both men and women.