Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Review of And Sometimes Why

And Sometimes Why
LaurieS avatar reviewed on + 504 more book reviews


This is a somewhat bland tale of friendship between two eighth graders that I doubt I would have finished had I not been listening to it on audio. It wasnt bad, just one those meh reads. Chris and Jack have been inseparable ever since their first meeting in the first grade. Jack is from the right side of the tracks but never fit in with the snotty country club set, while Chris is a girl who lives with her dad in a cozy apartment above a hair salon. This apparently means shes from the wrong side of the tracks as she states just like an old fogie at some point in the book. Maybe its just me or the kids I know, but when I spout out some old fart saying like that, Im called out on it and they always look at me like Im some oddity so hearing these kids talk like older folks pulled me out of the book more than a time or two.

Chris and Jack are growing up and Jack is starting to have issues with Chriss legs and the fact that so many guys are now noticing them. He fears losing her friendship and is having a difficult time seeing her with other guys and reacts with emotion, causing a rift between them. Making matters worse, Jacks parents have just separated and he fears his dad is having an affair. The story follows a few months in Jacks mildly tumultuous life as he sorts through all of these changes. If you toss away the old speak, its all realistic but not earth shattering stuff to get all excited about. My own childhood at this age was much more traumatic so Im probably not being fair to this novel. If youre really bored and looking for a mild tale about friendship you may love it.