Corey B. (coreyann) reviewed on 9/6/2007 + 34 more book reviews

Helpful Score: 4

This novel has its faults, a tried and true storyline that feels like it's pieces of her other novels and the original ending was a bit abrupt. I'm a bigger fan of her historical novels but I have liked all of her contemproaries thus far but EBYT fell a bit flat for me. However, when the paperback was released, McNaught reworked the ending (I think due to the outcry from her fans that something wasn't right about it) and it flows MUCH nicer now and the ending is perfect. Still not her best work but if you are going to read this novel, make sure you read the paperback.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details