I have read and enjoyed Neill's Chicagoland Vampire series so I was excited to hear about her new Devil's Isle series. It sounded like an interesting premise and I always enjoy storylines involving fey. It ended up being an okay book but not great. For some reason the story just seemed a little tired and boring to me.
I listened to this on audiobook and the audiobook was okay. Some of the male voices were stiff and cold sounding, especially Liam's voice. I had a hard time telling if it was the speech patterns and/or writing that made Liam sound stiff and cold, or if it was the narration. Either way this wasn't my favorite audiobook but it was okay.
I thought the idea of the Veil was incredibly interesting. Claire is okay as a character, but I wasn't totally engaged with her...she was just a bit too vanilla even with her Sensitive abilities. Liam was also an okay character but I never engaged with him all that well either; he was just so distant and cold.
The world is intriguing. Basically the people in this book have decided to stay in New Orleans despite the post-apocalyptic lifestyle to the area. While I found this interesting I also had a lot of trouble finding it believable and viable. I mean if the rest of the country had food, supplies, and technology why would sequester yourself in this little pocket of poverty and sparsity? I didn't get it and thought it was weird how isolated the story was; we really don't have a good idea what's happening in the world outside New Orleans. Additionally I am not a huge fan of New Orleans personally, so I wasn't crazy about the story being set there. I do understand that this is probably meant to echo New Orleans post-Katrina struggles, but I just didn't dig it.
Overall this was an okay book but not great. I liked the idea of the Veil but didn't find the world or characters all that engaging or interesting. There is quite a bit of action in this book but somehow it still felt tired and boring to me. I won't be reading future books in this series and wouldn't recommend it. I think Neill's Chicagoland series has also taken a turn for the worse in the last couple books; I am not sure if Neill's writing style is shifting or if I am just growing out of it.
I listened to this on audiobook and the audiobook was okay. Some of the male voices were stiff and cold sounding, especially Liam's voice. I had a hard time telling if it was the speech patterns and/or writing that made Liam sound stiff and cold, or if it was the narration. Either way this wasn't my favorite audiobook but it was okay.
I thought the idea of the Veil was incredibly interesting. Claire is okay as a character, but I wasn't totally engaged with her...she was just a bit too vanilla even with her Sensitive abilities. Liam was also an okay character but I never engaged with him all that well either; he was just so distant and cold.
The world is intriguing. Basically the people in this book have decided to stay in New Orleans despite the post-apocalyptic lifestyle to the area. While I found this interesting I also had a lot of trouble finding it believable and viable. I mean if the rest of the country had food, supplies, and technology why would sequester yourself in this little pocket of poverty and sparsity? I didn't get it and thought it was weird how isolated the story was; we really don't have a good idea what's happening in the world outside New Orleans. Additionally I am not a huge fan of New Orleans personally, so I wasn't crazy about the story being set there. I do understand that this is probably meant to echo New Orleans post-Katrina struggles, but I just didn't dig it.
Overall this was an okay book but not great. I liked the idea of the Veil but didn't find the world or characters all that engaging or interesting. There is quite a bit of action in this book but somehow it still felt tired and boring to me. I won't be reading future books in this series and wouldn't recommend it. I think Neill's Chicagoland series has also taken a turn for the worse in the last couple books; I am not sure if Neill's writing style is shifting or if I am just growing out of it.
Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
