Ron K. (WhidbeyIslander) - , reviewed on 7/29/2019 + 691 more book reviews

As usual the writing carries you along. However, there were a few aspects of this entry in the series I thought were not that great. The plot itself is very complicated, and although the authors flesh out a lot of the minor characters, some seem to appear for no reason other than padding. And once again Rutledge seems to spend a) a great deal of time motoring around and b) not sleeping enough. Why the Yard doesn't give him an iPad and access to the Internet to look up stuff is a mystery in itself. The re-emergence of Hamish was particularly troublesome; I'd hoped he was a thing of the past (so to speak.) Also annoying is the dependence on outlandish co-incidences which cause an eye-roll.

I usually envision Rutledge as I do the character of "Smithy" in Random Harvest -- also a shell-shocked WWI vet with memory issues -- as a young Ronald Colman, who played the character in the film.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details