Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Review of Maison Ikkoku, Volume 1

Maison Ikkoku, Volume 1
jedihanyou avatar reviewed on + 46 more book reviews


All Rumiko Takahashi's works that I have read are - in a word - amazing. This romantic comedy series is without a doubt one of the best such stories ever written. The main character is an average young man who (as is typical to manga heroes) somehow draws the attention multiple young ladies. However, uncharacteristic to manga, he only has feelings for one. His ties to the others are caused by a hilarious combination of cultural constrictions and happenstance. The female lead, a young widow, is torn between her growing feelings for the young man and the potential for a "safe" marriage to a charming, rich, handsome, and (unexpectedly) decent man.

The sheer indecisiveness of the primary characters is simultaneously amusing and frustrating. The annoying yet endearing supporting cast makes full use of Takahashi's characteristic flair for events happening at either the best time or the worst time possible - or both of those. The conclusion of the series will make you cry from sadness and joy at the same time, a clear indication of high-quality writing.

I only rate this edition 4.5 stars instead of 5 because the re-printed edition (which simply numbers the volumes rather than naming them) includes chapters that the first edition left out. CAUTION: I do not advise buying a mixture of the two because the volumes do NOT match up. Ex: volume 1 of one version has the first 10 chapters, the other version has the first 11.