Julie Y. (naboo) reviewed on + 53 more book reviews
This is the second book I have read by this author, and I thought A Place At the Table was much better.
The story begins in 1993 with Ruthie, 12 years old, and Julia, 16 years old, are close half-sisters whose lives are traumatized after their parents, Naomi and Phil Harrison, die in a small-plane crash over the Grand Canyon. As a result, Ruthie ends up living with Mimi (Phil's sister) and Robert in San Francisco while Julia winds up living with Matthew (her biological father) and her stepmother Peggy in Virden, Virginia. Ruthie happens to be the protagonist.
Unfortunately, the sisters deal with the death of their parents differently. Ruthie does well in school, receives therapy, and becomes friends with Dora while living with her rich aunt and uncle. Regrettably, Julia rebels and skips school, drinks, smokes, and takes drugs, thus forcing her father and stepmother to send her to a Fundamentalist rehab center.
The story continues on until 2009, relating the complex relationship between Ruthie and Julia.
I enjoyed that the author included the events of 9/11 in light of Julia living in New York at that time. Furthermore, Julia happens to be one of the passengers on the US Airways Flight 1549 that crash landed on-the-go Hudson River on January 15, 2009.
Anyway, I felt like this book had great potential, but the ending was quite strange. It felt like the author did not know how to end the story, so she just stopped writing. For example, Ruthie and Gabe, her husband, had an argument about children - he wanted them, but she did not. Also, Julia was planning on writing a memoir about her childhood, and Ruthie was still mad at her regarding her previous non-fiction novel. Julia had included information surrounding Ruthie's abortion without her knowledge.
The story begins in 1993 with Ruthie, 12 years old, and Julia, 16 years old, are close half-sisters whose lives are traumatized after their parents, Naomi and Phil Harrison, die in a small-plane crash over the Grand Canyon. As a result, Ruthie ends up living with Mimi (Phil's sister) and Robert in San Francisco while Julia winds up living with Matthew (her biological father) and her stepmother Peggy in Virden, Virginia. Ruthie happens to be the protagonist.
Unfortunately, the sisters deal with the death of their parents differently. Ruthie does well in school, receives therapy, and becomes friends with Dora while living with her rich aunt and uncle. Regrettably, Julia rebels and skips school, drinks, smokes, and takes drugs, thus forcing her father and stepmother to send her to a Fundamentalist rehab center.
The story continues on until 2009, relating the complex relationship between Ruthie and Julia.
I enjoyed that the author included the events of 9/11 in light of Julia living in New York at that time. Furthermore, Julia happens to be one of the passengers on the US Airways Flight 1549 that crash landed on-the-go Hudson River on January 15, 2009.
Anyway, I felt like this book had great potential, but the ending was quite strange. It felt like the author did not know how to end the story, so she just stopped writing. For example, Ruthie and Gabe, her husband, had an argument about children - he wanted them, but she did not. Also, Julia was planning on writing a memoir about her childhood, and Ruthie was still mad at her regarding her previous non-fiction novel. Julia had included information surrounding Ruthie's abortion without her knowledge.
Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
