Reynolds is best known for a cartoon series, Reynolds Unwrapped.

His work appears in almost every issue of Reader's Digest (where he is known for his cow, pig and chicken cartoons) and in stores featuring major greeting cards published by Recycled Paper Greetings, Papyrus and Nobleworks.

Reynolds' work also appeared in the opening episode of the 2002 episode of HBO's The Sopranos and the cover of a National Lampoon cartoon book collection. His baseball cartoons are in the Cooperstown National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.