Thomas F. (hardtack) - , reviewed on 7/23/2023 + 2682 more book reviews

While a very interesting book about our buying habits and how retailers must take a second look at their displays and store arrangements, it was also very repetitive. I agree with Naomi's review that many of the chapters in the middle were just "story telling" and of little use. In fact, I got a bit tired of the author telling us men are different than women, something I was very cognizant of before I left elementary school.

The middle chapters were also full of streams of randomized thoughts about product placement that often didn't make sense. As if the author was tossing out thoughts in a stream of consciousness without really considering them. In fact, there were many I believe would not work effectively.

Still, other reviewers are correct in saying retailers should read this book. In fact, I came across several really good ideas I'd like to see made in the arrangement of items at the thrift store where I volunteer. What made it really interesting was the chapter "The Self Exam," as there were a number of pages about how stores can sell books better, which made for interesting reading.

This book was published in 1999. This means a number of its examples are no longer meaningful in the 24 years since then. The middle chapters contain a lot of these examples, and what I remembered from them was not the sales hints but the dated examples. And I had to chuckle at his statement, "...the internet is never going to seriously challenge reality-based retailing." (page 214)

Well, I dined out this past Friday. On my way home, I drove past the large mall our town has. I realized I hadn't been in there for well over 10 years, so I stopped just to stroll though it. Many of the store fronts were empty, most of the remainder were clothing, shoe or jewelry stores. The last I understood, as I never could understand why someone would buy jewelry online. But there were very few shoppers and the mall was closing at 9 pm. In fact, many of the stores were already closed.

But, as I am an entomologist, what really upset me was a random comment he made on page 167, when he wrote, "You might say that the ant is searching for suitable food. I say he is shopping." What! The only males in ant colonies are the male swarmers which usually emerge once a year. If that ant was out searching for food, then it was a worker ant, and they are all sterile females. So, you see, he doesn't know as much as he says he does. :-)

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details