Ford's approach has its detractors, and criticism has included that her methods are like "training animals". Critics of her methods include Penelope Leach, Miriam Stoppard and Nick Clegg. However, there are many proponents of Ford's methods, including Eammon Holmes and Michelle Gayle.

In response to criticism levied against her, Ford suggests that the 25% market share of children's books that her publications enjoy is proof that her methods do not harm children.

In 2004, the BBC commissioned a series from Outline Productions called Gina Ford's Baby School, using Big Brother-style methods to oversee the progress of newborn babies. In January 2005, Ford had a meeting with BBC and Outline Productions, and refused to agree to certain reality-style aspects of the format. With only a few weeks before filming, Ford pulled out and was replaced by Dr Tanya Byron.

Five Life commissioned a programme called Gina Ford: Who Are You To Tell Us?, which aired on 4 March 2007.

Ford has threatened legal action against online child and parenting forum mumsnet.com, claiming that users have made "defamatory" comments about her, and has demanded that the whole site be taken down. In May 2007, this dispute was resolved with Mumsnet paying some of Ford's legal costs, but Mumsnet remaining open.

In 2007, she wrote to the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children and accused fellow child-care expert Claire Verity of “child abuse” for methods used in a Channel 4 series called Bringing Up Baby.